Skip to main content
Investing · ETFs

The 10 biggest ETF mistakes UK retail makes

Low-cost ETFs are simple to buy, but the same handful of mistakes can quietly cost investors money: fees, currency, concentration, leverage, spreads, tax and behaviour. Each is avoidable once you know what to look for.

By · Reviewed

The 10 mistakes: (1) buying high-cost ETFs when low-cost equivalents exist, (2) currency-misunderstanding (FX-hedged vs unhedged), (3) over-concentrating in UK-only indices, (4) chasing thematic ETFs at peak hype, (5) buying leveraged ETFs for long-term holding, (6) ignoring the bid-ask spread on smaller ETFs, (7) holding ETFs outside an ISA without tracking reportable income, (8) failing to rebalance between asset classes, (9) selling on market drops, (10) over-trading instead of buy-and-hold. Each is fixable.

Mistake 1 — Buying high-cost ETFs when low-cost equivalents exist

Take two ETFs tracking the same S&P 500 index, one with an ongoing charge (OCF) of 0.07% and one at 0.25%. If the index returns 7% a year for 30 years, the cheaper fund ends up about 5% larger, purely because of the 0.18 percentage point difference in fees compounding over time.

Fix: Before buying any ETF, check the OCF on its factsheet or key information document. Broad-market trackers (S&P 500, FTSE 100, global indices) are widely available for well under 0.25% a year, and several large providers offer them. If a fund costs much more than similar funds tracking the same index, find out why before buying.

Mistake 2 — FX-hedged vs unhedged confusion

A sterling-hedged S&P 500 ETF aims to give you roughly the US market's return in dollars, with most of the effect of the pound-dollar exchange rate removed (hedging has a small cost). An unhedged fund leaves you exposed to currency moves: if the pound rises against the dollar, your return in pounds falls, and if it falls, your return rises.

Currency swings can add or remove a large slice of return over a year or two. Over long periods they matter less than the performance of the shares themselves, but they do not disappear.

Fix: For long-term equity holdings, unhedged funds are a common choice; currency adds noise rather than a reliable gain or loss. Hedging removes currency risk, not market risk, so if you need the money within a few years, ask whether shares are suitable at all. See the FX hedging decision framework.

Mistake 3 — Over-concentrating in UK-only indices

The UK made up 3.11% of the MSCI ACWI global equity index at 31 August 2026; the US was 63.59%. A portfolio that is mostly FTSE 100 shares is a large bet on one country and its 100 largest listed companies.

That bet can go either way. In US dollars, the MSCI United Kingdom index returned 9.15% a year over the 10 years to 31 August 2026, against 13.01% for MSCI World; over the last 5 years the UK was ahead, at 12.96% a year against 11.21%. Concentration means your result depends heavily on one country.

Fix: Many investors use a global ETF as the core of their equity holdings and add a UK tilt only if they want one. How much to hold in the UK is a personal choice; the point is to make it a deliberate one.

Mistake 4 — Chasing thematic ETFs at peak hype

Thematic ETFs (clean energy, blockchain, robotics, AI and so on) often launch, and attract most of their money, after a theme has already risen strongly. When enthusiasm fades, late buyers can face steep losses, and narrow funds can close if they fail to attract enough assets.

Fix: Investors who want a theme often keep it to a small part of the portfolio, because narrow funds can fall sharply. A broad global fund already holds the large companies in most themes, in proportion to their size.

Mistake 5 — Buying leveraged ETFs for long-term holding

2x and 3x leveraged ETPs aim to deliver a multiple of the index's return over a single day, and reset every day. Over longer periods the result can be very different from 2 or 3 times the index, especially in choppy markets.

A simple example: the index rises 10% one day and falls 10% the next, ending 1% down (1.10 x 0.90 = 0.99). A 2x product rises 20% then falls 20%, ending 4% down (1.20 x 0.80 = 0.96). Repeat that pattern and the gap widens, even if the index ends where it started.

Fix: Leveraged products are designed around one day's return, and the product's key information document describes this daily reset; held for weeks or months, the result can differ widely from 2 or 3 times the index. Borrowing to invest magnifies losses as well as gains.

Mistake 6 — Ignoring the bid-ask spread on smaller ETFs

Every ETF trade has a spread: the gap between the price you pay and the price you could sell at. On large, heavily traded ETFs it is usually tiny. On small or niche ETFs it can be several tenths of a percent or more, so a round trip can cost more than years of savings from a slightly lower OCF.

Fix: The live bid and offer prices show the spread before you deal. Spreads tend to be wider in the first and last minutes of the trading day, and larger funds usually trade on tighter spreads, which matters most for big purchases. For small regular investments the spread matters less than the fee.

Mistake 7 — Holding ETFs outside an ISA without tracking reportable income

Most ETFs sold to UK investors are offshore funds (often based in Ireland) with UK "reporting fund" status. Each year they report their income per share. Outside an ISA or pension, you are taxed on your share of that reported income whether or not it is paid out, according to HMRC's offshore funds helpsheet HS265:

Fix: Inside an ISA or SIPP none of this applies. Outside them, check the fund is on HMRC's reporting funds list, download its annual report of income each year, and include the figures on your tax return where you need to. See the wrapper tax matrix.

Mistake 8 — Failing to rebalance between asset classes

If you never rebalance, the mix drifts towards whatever has risen most. As an illustration, if shares return 10% a year and bonds 3% a year for 10 years, a 60/40 shares/bonds portfolio becomes about 74/26, so it carries more risk than you chose just when a fall would hurt most.

Fix: Common approaches are to rebalance on a schedule (for example once a year) or when an allocation drifts a set distance, such as 5 percentage points, from target. Many platforms can do this automatically. See the rebalancing guide.

Mistake 9 — Selling on market drops

The hardest behavioural challenge. In US dollars, MSCI World fell 18.1% in 2022, then rose 23.8% in 2023 and 18.7% in 2024. An investor who sold during the 2022 fall and waited for things to "settle" missed much of the recovery. The index's worst fall since 2000 was 57.8%, between October 2007 and March 2009, and it later recovered that too, though it took years.

Fix: Some investors write down a rule in advance, for example: "I will not sell broad-market funds because of a fall unless my time horizon has changed." Regular monthly investing means buying continues when prices are lower. Money needed within about 5 years has less time to recover from a fall, which is why it is often held in cash rather than shares.

Mistake 10 — Over-trading instead of buy-and-hold

Every trade costs a spread and sometimes a dealing fee, and outside an ISA each sale can create a taxable gain. Frequent trading also tends to mean buying after rises and selling after falls, which adds a behavioural cost on top of the direct costs.

Fix: Each switch between similar funds costs a spread, sometimes a dealing fee and, outside an ISA, possibly tax on a gain. Many broad-market investors keep a set mix, invest regularly and rebalance occasionally, making changes at the asset-allocation level rather than swapping between similar funds.

A simple example portfolio

This is an illustration of how simple a diversified ETF portfolio can be, not a recommendation for you. The right mix depends on your goals, time horizon and attitude to risk.

Two or three funds plus cash, held for the long term and rebalanced occasionally, avoids most of the mistakes above.

Sources and methodology

Checked on 3 October 2026.

The fee, leverage and rebalancing figures are our own arithmetic on the stated assumptions. This page is general information, not a personal recommendation; for advice on your own investments use a financial adviser authorised by the FCA. The methodology page explains how we source and check figures.

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.