To rebalance a UK ISA portfolio: (1) decide your trigger — either calendar (e.g. once a year in April) or threshold (e.g. 5 percentage points from target); (2) prefer contribution-only rebalancing where possible — direct new money toward underweight assets instead of selling existing holdings; (3) inside an ISA there is no Capital Gains Tax, so selling costs only dealing charges and spreads; (4) outside an ISA, in a general investment account, gains above the £3,000 annual exempt amount are taxed at 18% or 24% in 2026/27, so use contributions first; (5) keep it simple — rebalancing too often adds cost without adding much risk control.
Why rebalance at all
Without rebalancing, a portfolio drifts toward whichever asset has done best. Vanguard gives a real example: a portfolio of 60% global equities and 40% global bonds at the end of 2003, never rebalanced, would have held 80% in equities by the end of 2022. The arithmetic is simple: if equities return 8% a year and bonds 3%, a 60/40 portfolio left alone is about 71/29 after 10 years and about 79/21 after 20 years.
- Risk control (the main reason). Drift means you are taking more risk than you chose. The point of holding bonds is to limit drawdowns; a portfolio that has drifted to 80% equities has lost much of that protection. Vanguard's research says the primary job of rebalancing is to keep a portfolio in line with your tolerance for risk, not to maximise returns.
- A built-in rule to sell high and buy low. Rebalancing makes you trim what has risen and add to what has fallen, which can help in markets that swing back and forth. In markets where the winner keeps winning, it can cost return instead.
The three rebalancing approaches
Approach A: Calendar rebalancing
Pick a date and rebalance on that date regardless of drift. A common choice is once a year, for example at the start of the tax year (6 April) or at the end of the calendar year.
Pros: Simple, disciplined, removes timing emotion.
Cons: Can trade when drift is minimal. Can miss large drifts mid-year.
Approach B: Threshold rebalancing
Rebalance whenever an asset class drifts more than a set amount from target, for example 5 percentage points. Check monthly or quarterly.
Pros: Only acts when drift is meaningful.
Cons: Requires regular monitoring. Can trigger several rebalances in volatile years.
Approach C: Contribution-only rebalancing
Direct new contributions (and dividends, if you take them as cash) toward the underweight asset class until it returns to target. No selling required. Vanguard recommends using cash flows this way where you can.
Pros: No extra trading costs, no Capital Gains Tax exposure in a general investment account, no behavioural drama.
Cons: Slow to correct large drifts. Works best while you are still adding money.
Step-by-step annual rebalance
ISA vs GIA — different rebalancing rules
| Wrapper | Selling generates... | Rebalancing approach |
|---|---|---|
| ISA | No tax | Rebalance freely |
| Pension (SIPP) | No tax | Rebalance freely |
| GIA (taxable account) | Capital Gains Tax on gains above the £3,000 annual exempt amount (18% or 24% on shares and funds in 2026/27) | Use contributions first; sell gains up to the £3,000 allowance where you can |
| Lifetime ISA | No tax | Rebalance freely inside it; withdrawals other than for a first home, after 60 or terminal illness carry a charge |
Worked example: rebalancing a £200,000 ISA after a strong equity year
Start of year: £140,000 equity (70%), £50,000 bonds (25%), £10,000 cash (5%). Target: 70/25/5.
End of year, after equities rise 18% and bonds 2% (cash interest ignored to keep it simple):
- Equity: £165,200 (73.0%)
- Bonds: £51,000 (22.5%)
- Cash: £10,000 (4.4%)
- Total: £226,200
Equity is 3 points over target. Under the 5-point rule above, no sale is needed: you would point new contributions at bonds and cash. Under a strict once-a-year rule, you would rebalance to £158,340 equity (70%), £56,550 bonds (25%) and £11,310 cash (5%): sell £6,860 of equity, buy £5,550 of bonds and keep £1,310 as cash.
Inside an ISA there is no tax to pay on the sale. In a general investment account, the same £6,860 sale could realise a gain that counts towards the £3,000 annual exempt amount.
Costs and frequency
Each rebalance has two costs: the platform's dealing charge per trade (many charge a few pounds per online ETF trade, and some charge nothing; check your platform's charges page) and the bid-offer spread, which for large, widely traded ETFs is usually a small fraction of a percent. Because dealing charges are per trade, rebalancing more often multiplies them.
Example: the cost of one rebalance
Moving £5,000 from one ETF to another with a £5 dealing charge on each trade and a spread cost of 0.1% on each trade comes to about £20: £10 in charges plus £10 in spreads (0.1% of £5,000 sold and of £5,000 bought). On a £100,000 portfolio that is 0.02% if you do it once a year. If you did the same every month it would be about £240 a year, or 0.24%.
Vanguard's research is that neither extreme works well: rebalancing monthly or quarterly adds cost, while waiting two years or more lets risk drift too far. It found annual rebalancing more efficient than quarterly or monthly in volatile markets once transaction costs are counted.
Common rebalancing mistakes
Project compound growth
The compound interest calculator shows how regular contributions can grow over decades at the return you choose.
Open compound interest calculator →Sources and references
Checked on 3 October 2026:
- Vanguard UK, Why, how and when multi-asset investors should rebalance (4 January 2026): the 60/40 drift example (end-2003 to end-2022), risk control as the primary purpose, using cash flows, and frequency.
- GOV.UK, Capital Gains Tax: allowances: the £3,000 annual exempt amount.
- GOV.UK, Capital Gains Tax: rates: 18% and 24% on gains from 6 April 2026.
- GOV.UK, Individual Savings Accounts: no tax on gains or income inside an ISA, and the £20,000 allowance for 2026/27.
- GOV.UK, Lifetime ISA: the permitted uses and the withdrawal charge.
UK Tax Drag is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority and does not provide regulated financial or tax advice — see the content disclaimer for the full position. There are no affiliate links on this page.
Other investing how-to guides
- How to open a SIPP
- Cash ISA vs Stocks & Shares ISA vs LISA — which to choose
- How to build a 3-fund portfolio in a UK ISA
- Drip-feed vs lump-sum invest — the UK research
- How to switch from active to passive investing
- How to take income from investments in retirement
- How to claim foreign withholding tax on US ETFs (W-8BEN)
- How to do bed-and-ISA without triggering CGT
- Investing hub
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.