Skip to main content
Free Calculator · 2026/27

Annuity vs Drawdown Calculator

Compare buying a guaranteed annuity income with staying in flexible drawdown. See cumulative income, remaining pot value, and the breakeven longevity at which each option wins.

Educational only. Annuity rates change often and differ between providers, including your own pension provider; the rates entered here are assumptions, not quotes.
By · Reviewed

Your retirement pot and assumptions

£50k£2m
5585
3%10%
3%8%
0%10%
75100
Breakeven age
—
The first age at which total annuity income catches up with total drawdown withdrawals
£0Annuity guaranteed annual income
£0Drawdown year-1 income at chosen rate
£0Drawdown pot value at end of horizon
Cumulative income — annuity vs drawdown
Annuity (cumulative) Drawdown (cumulative)

How to read the result

Annuity exchanges the entire pot for a guaranteed lifetime income. The income amount is fixed at purchase (or rises by RPI / fixed % if you bought an escalating annuity at a lower starting rate). The pot is used up: unless the annuity includes a guarantee period, value protection or a spouse's pension, nothing passes on at death.

Drawdown keeps the pot invested and you withdraw a chosen percentage each year. In this calculator the withdrawal is a fixed percentage of whatever the pot is worth at the start of each year, so the income rises or falls with the pot. The remaining pot at death is inheritable (and tax-efficient if death is before age 75).

The longevity trade-off

Annuities protect against living a long time: the longer you live, the more the annuity pays in total. Drawdown keeps the money invested and yours: what is left at death can pass on, but the pot can run down if you live a long time or returns are poor. The breakeven age above is the first age at which the annuity's total payments catch up with the total drawdown withdrawals. It compares income only; the drawdown pot left at the end of the projection is shown separately.

What the calculator doesn't model

When annuity tends to win

When drawdown tends to win

The hybrid approach

A split is also possible: part of the pot buys an annuity that, with the State Pension, covers essential spending, and the rest stays in drawdown. That limits longevity risk on the essentials while keeping flexibility, and a possible inheritance, on the rest. The calculator above doesn't model a split, but running it twice, once for each part of the pot, approximates one.

Pension drawdown tax calculator · Tax-free lump sum calculator · State Pension forecast · FIRE calculator

Annuity vs Drawdown — head to head

The two main ways to convert a UK defined-contribution pension into retirement income. They carry different risks, and part of a pot can go each way.

Dimension AnnuityFlexi-access drawdown
Income certaintyGuaranteed for life (level or index-linked)Variable — depends on investment returns and your withdrawal rate
FlexibilityLocked in once purchasedChange income levels at any time
Death benefitsUsually ends on death (unless joint life or guarantee period)Remaining pot passes to nominated beneficiaries
Longevity riskInsurer carries it — you can't outlive the incomeYou carry it — pot can deplete if you live longer than expected
Investment riskNone after purchaseYou bear it — market drops affect remaining pot
Inflation protectionOnly with index-linked annuity (lower starting income)Built in if real returns exceed withdrawal rate
Tax treatment25% tax-free lump sum, then taxable income at marginal rate25% tax-free, then taxable on withdrawal
Annual allowance triggerNo MPAA trigger for a lifetime annuity whose payments cannot fall (a flexible annuity does trigger it)Triggers MPAA (£10k cap on future money purchase contributions) as soon as taxable income taken
Income levelSet by the quote at purchase; rates move with gilt yields and depend on age, health and the type of annuityWhatever is withdrawn; no withdrawal rate is guaranteed to last
ChargesBuilt into the rate (no separate ongoing charge)Ongoing platform, fund and any adviser charges, taken from the pot
Main trade-offCertainty of income for life, in exchange for giving up the potFlexibility and a possible inheritance, in exchange for investment and longevity risk

Figures use 2026/27 UK tax-year rates and thresholds. Verify your specific situation against HMRC, FCA or MoneyHelper guidance before deciding.

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.