Your retirement pot and assumptions
How to read the result
Annuity exchanges the entire pot for a guaranteed lifetime income. The income amount is fixed at purchase (or rises by RPI / fixed % if you bought an escalating annuity at a lower starting rate). The pot is used up: unless the annuity includes a guarantee period, value protection or a spouse's pension, nothing passes on at death.
Drawdown keeps the pot invested and you withdraw a chosen percentage each year. In this calculator the withdrawal is a fixed percentage of whatever the pot is worth at the start of each year, so the income rises or falls with the pot. The remaining pot at death is inheritable (and tax-efficient if death is before age 75).
The longevity trade-off
Annuities protect against living a long time: the longer you live, the more the annuity pays in total. Drawdown keeps the money invested and yours: what is left at death can pass on, but the pot can run down if you live a long time or returns are poor. The breakeven age above is the first age at which the annuity's total payments catch up with the total drawdown withdrawals. It compares income only; the drawdown pot left at the end of the projection is shown separately.
What the calculator doesn't model
- Sequence-of-returns risk — drawdown's biggest hidden danger. The calculator applies the same return every year, but real returns vary: a fall in the pot's value early in retirement, while withdrawals continue, can leave it permanently smaller even if the long-run average return matches the assumption.
- Inflation. The annuity rate above is assumed level (not RPI-linked). An inflation-linked annuity bought with the same pot starts at a lower income than a level one, then rises over time.
- Spousal benefits. Joint-life annuities continue to pay a percentage to a surviving spouse but at a reduced rate; the calculator assumes single-life.
- Enhanced annuities. Insurers may offer a higher income to people with certain health conditions or lifestyle factors, such as smoking, because they expect to pay the income for a shorter time; this depends on the medical or lifestyle information given to the insurer.
- The 25% tax-free lump sum. This calculator assumes the entire pot goes into either the annuity or drawdown. Up to 25% can usually be taken tax-free first (within the Lump Sum Allowance, £268,275 for most people), and Income Tax on the rest is not modelled.
When annuity tends to win
- You live well beyond average life expectancy.
- You're risk-averse and the certainty of the income matters more than the residual estate.
- Annuity rates are high at the time of purchase (they tend to move with long-term gilt yields).
- You qualify for an enhanced annuity due to health.
When drawdown tends to win
- You die earlier than average — heirs receive a meaningful pot.
- Investment returns turn out higher than the return the insurer builds into the annuity rate at purchase.
- You want flexibility to take more in some years and less in others.
- Your other income (State Pension, partner's income) covers your essential spending, so drawdown only funds discretionary expenses.
The hybrid approach
A split is also possible: part of the pot buys an annuity that, with the State Pension, covers essential spending, and the rest stays in drawdown. That limits longevity risk on the essentials while keeping flexibility, and a possible inheritance, on the rest. The calculator above doesn't model a split, but running it twice, once for each part of the pot, approximates one.
Related calculators
Pension drawdown tax calculator · Tax-free lump sum calculator · State Pension forecast · FIRE calculator
Annuity vs Drawdown — head to head
The two main ways to convert a UK defined-contribution pension into retirement income. They carry different risks, and part of a pot can go each way.
Figures use 2026/27 UK tax-year rates and thresholds. Verify your specific situation against HMRC, FCA or MoneyHelper guidance before deciding.
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.