Skip to main content
Investing · ETFs

Why your tracker isn't matching the index

You buy an S&P 500 tracker, the news says the S&P 500 is up 12%, and your fund shows something different. Most of the time the explanation is currency, timing or the way the return is measured, and the fund itself is within a fraction of a percentage point of its index. Here is how to tell the difference, and when a gap is worth worrying about.

By · Reviewed

A tracker's yearly gap from its index (its tracking difference) has five main causes: (1) charges, which come straight off the return; (2) sampling, where a fund holds a representative selection rather than every stock; (3) dividends and withholding tax, where timing and the tax rate the index assumes can push the fund slightly ahead or behind; (4) currency, which is not a tracking problem at all if you compare a sterling return with a dollar index; and (5) securities lending, which can add a little income. For a large, low-cost equity tracker, a gap no bigger than its charge (or a small lead over the index) is normal. A shortfall well beyond the charge, year after year, is worth investigating.

Tracking difference and tracking error

Two terms get mixed up:

Most of this page is about tracking difference: why a fund's return over a year is a little above or below its index.

Cause 1: charges

The ongoing charge (OCF, or TER) is taken from the fund continuously, so it comes straight off the return. A tracker charging 0.07% a year would, other things being equal, trail its index by about 0.07 percentage points a year. Over 30 years a 0.07% charge leaves the final value about 2% lower than it would otherwise be.

Comparing charges between two funds tracking the same index is a sensible starting point, but the lower charge does not guarantee the smaller gap. Check the fund's actual record against its index, because the other causes below can add to or offset the charge.

Cause 2: full replication or sampling

A fund using full replication holds every stock in the index at its index weight. iShares Core S&P 500 (CSPX), for example, uses physical replication and held 505 lines on 1 October 2026.

For very broad indices, some funds use optimised sampling: they hold a representative selection designed to behave like the index. iShares Core MSCI World (SWDA) uses this method and held 1,250 lines on 1 October 2026. Sampling keeps trading costs down but means the fund will not match the index exactly, and the gap can go either way.

The fund's factsheet or product page states its method ("physical replication", "optimised" or "sampled"), and the prospectus explains how it tracks the index.

Cause 3: dividends and withholding tax

A total return index assumes dividends are reinvested from the day a share goes ex-dividend. A real fund receives the cash later and holds it until it is reinvested or paid out, which causes small timing differences in either direction.

Withholding tax matters more. Many funds are measured against a "net" total return index, which deducts dividend withholding tax at set rates. If a fund suffers less withholding tax than the index assumes (because of the tax treaties available to it), it can beat its index; if it suffers more, it lags. This is one reason a low-cost tracker can come out slightly ahead of its benchmark.

Cause 4: currency (not really tracking at all)

This causes the most confusion. The S&P 500 is usually quoted in US dollars. If you hold an S&P 500 fund and measure your return in pounds, exchange-rate moves come into it:

That is not a tracking problem; it is a different unit of measurement. Compare like with like: a fund's sterling return with the index's sterling return, or its dollar return with the dollar index. Providers usually publish performance in the fund's base currency.

Cause 5: securities lending

Some funds lend shares to other institutions for a fee, backed by collateral. The fund keeps part of the fee, which can offset some of its costs. Not every fund lends, and the amounts are often small: on 3 October 2026 iShares showed a securities lending return of 0.00% for CSPX and 0.02% for SWDA (both as at 30 June 2026).

Lending adds counterparty and operational risk, which the collateral is meant to cover. Each fund's prospectus and annual report say whether it lends, how much, and how the revenue is shared between the fund and the lending agent.

When is the gap worth worrying about?

A rough guide for broad equity index funds, comparing the yearly tracking difference with the fund's own charge (our rule of thumb, not an official standard):

Tracking difference over several yearsLikely explanationWhat to do
Ahead of the index, or behind it by no more than the chargeCharges offset by withholding-tax advantages, lending income or good tradingNothing: the fund is tracking well
Behind by the charge plus up to about 0.1 to 0.2 pointsCharges plus sampling, cash drag or trading costsUsually acceptable; compare with other funds tracking the same index
Behind by noticeably more than the charge, year after yearHigher hidden costs, a less efficient method or a tax disadvantageRead the annual report's explanation and compare it with other funds tracking the same index over several years

One bad year can be noise. Look at several calendar years before drawing conclusions.

Worked example: two iShares trackers

iShares publishes each fund's calendar-year return next to its benchmark. These figures were read from the iShares product pages on 3 October 2026 (US dollars, on a net asset value basis):

FundCharge (TER)2024 fund / index2025 fund / indexTracking difference
iShares Core S&P 500 (CSPX), physical replication0.07%24.7% / 24.5%17.6% / 17.4%+0.2 points in each year
iShares Core MSCI World (SWDA), optimised sampling0.20%18.7% / 18.7%21.2% / 21.1%0.0 and +0.1 points

Both funds matched or beat their benchmarks even after their charges, which shows that the charge is only part of the story: the other causes above more than offset it in these years. The figures are rounded to one decimal place and past performance does not predict future returns. If you hold a sterling-listed line of a fund, the provider's figures in the base currency are still the right comparison with the index.

How to check your own fund

  1. Open the fund's product page or factsheet and find the calendar-year returns for the fund and its benchmark, in the same currency.
  2. Subtract the index return from the fund return for each year to get the tracking difference.
  3. Read the latest annual report. Under the European regulator's guidelines for index-tracking UCITS funds, which Irish and Luxembourg ETFs follow, the annual report states the tracking error, explains any gap from the expected level, and discloses and explains the annual tracking difference.
  4. Compare with other funds tracking the same index, over several years rather than one.

What isn't the fund's tracking gap

Sources and methodology

The fund figures on this page were checked against these sources on 3 October 2026:

If you want personal advice on choosing funds, check that any adviser is authorised on the FCA Financial Services Register. The methodology page explains how pages are checked.

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.