Skip to main content
Property · SDLT

SDLT on mixed-use property: when commercial rates apply

A purchase that includes both residential and non-residential property — a flat above a shop, a farmhouse sold with a working farm, a pub with a manager's flat — pays the non-residential rates of Stamp Duty, with no 5% surcharge. On an expensive purchase the difference runs to tens of thousands of pounds. The hard cases are houses sold with paddocks, fields or woodland, where the question is whether the land is the "garden or grounds" of the house, and tribunals have decided those both ways on the facts. This is the 2026/27 position in England and Northern Ireland, and where the line sits.

By · Reviewed

A purchase is "mixed-use" for SDLT when what you buy includes both residential property and land or buildings that are not residential at completion. It is then taxed at the non-residential rates (0% on the first £150,000, 2% on £150,001 to £250,000, 5% above) rather than the residential rates, and the 5% higher rates for additional dwellings cannot apply. Genuine cases include flats above shops and farmhouses sold with a working farm. For a house sold with extra land, the test is whether that land is the garden or grounds of the house: claims based on a grazing agreement have both failed and succeeded at tribunal, so the facts decide.

The headline saving

Residential and non-residential purchases use different bands, so the two tables below are not side by side slice for slice.

Residential rates, England and Northern Ireland, 2026/27
Price sliceStandard rateWith 5% higher rates
Up to £125,0000%5%
£125,001 to £250,0002%7%
£250,001 to £925,0005%10%
£925,001 to £1.5 million10%15%
Above £1.5 million12%17%
Non-residential and mixed-use rates, 2026/27
Price sliceRate
Up to £150,0000%
£150,001 to £250,0002%
Above £250,0005%

Worked example, £1.2 million purchase:

So mixed-use status would save £14,250 against standard residential rates, or £74,250 where the higher rates would otherwise apply. That gap is why these claims get close attention from HMRC.

What counts as "mixed use"

Finance Act 2003 section 55(1B) uses the residential table only where the land bought "consists entirely of residential property". If it "consists of or includes" land that is not residential property, the non-residential table applies to the whole price. Section 116 defines residential property as a building used or suitable for use as a dwelling, the garden or grounds of such a building (including buildings on that land), and rights that benefit them. Anything else is non-residential.

Purchases that are usually mixed-use:

Separately, buying 6 or more dwellings in a single transaction lets you use the non-residential rates instead of the residential ones (section 116(7)).

What does NOT count (despite buyers' hopes)

What HMRC looks at

There is no size limit and no "reasonable enjoyment" test for garden or grounds (SDLTM00440). HMRC's manual says to look for the "traditional or habitual use" of the land, its layout and how it relates to the house, and it says use that is "ephemeral or appears to be part of an artificial/contrived arrangement" does not show the true position (SDLTM00450).

Evidence that helps where the claim is genuine: leases or grazing agreements and how long they have run, rent records, business rates entries, agricultural use, how the land is fenced off and reached, and whether it is hidden from or used with the house. You do not send evidence with the return, but HMRC expects you to keep it and produce it if asked.

Recent tribunal cases: what has been argued

Hyman and Goodfellow v HMRC, Court of Appeal, 2022

Mr and Mrs Hyman bought a house near St Albans with 3.5 acres, mostly meadow, beside a public bridleway. Dr and Mrs Goodfellow bought a house in Hampshire with 4.5 acres including a stable yard and paddocks. Both argued that land beyond what was needed for the reasonable enjoyment of the house was not residential. The Court of Appeal rejected any such limit and dismissed both appeals, so the residential rates applied: £34,950 more for the Hymans and £48,500 more for the Goodfellows ([2022] EWCA Civ 185, 17 February 2022).

Withers v HMRC, First-tier Tribunal, 2022

Mr Withers bought Lake Farm in Kent: a house and annexe with about 39 acres. About 20 acres had been grazed by a local farmer's sheep since 2001, latterly under a written agreement; the fields had been bought separately as agricultural land, were hidden from the house and had never been used with it. The tribunal found that part of the land was not grounds, so the mixed-use rates applied and HMRC's £98,000 increase fell away ([2022] UKFTT 433 (TC), 25 November 2022).

Faiers v HMRC, First-tier Tribunal, 2023

Mr Faiers bought Agester Lodge near Canterbury, then amended his return to claim mixed-use rates because an electricity distribution network crossed the land under a wayleave. The tribunal held that the power lines did not stop the land being the grounds of the house, and dismissed the appeal ([2023] UKFTT 297 (TC), 14 March 2023).

HMRC v Suterwalla, Upper Tribunal, 2024

Mr and Mrs Suterwalla bought a house near Henley-on-Thames with gardens, a tennis court and a paddock on a separate title, and granted a grazing lease over the paddock on the day of completion. The First-tier Tribunal found the paddock was not part of the grounds. HMRC appealed, and the Upper Tribunal dismissed the appeal because that finding was open to the tribunal on the evidence. The SDLT stayed at £169,500 rather than HMRC's £330,750 ([2024] UKUT 188 (TCC), 1 July 2024).

The lesson: there is no size test, and the outcome turns on how the land has actually been used and laid out. Land that is separate from the house, with a long history of farming or business use, has the best chance. Land that looks and functions like part of the house's grounds usually stays residential, whatever arrangement is put in place around completion.

Multiple Dwellings Relief (MDR) is gone

Until 1 June 2024, buyers of more than one dwelling could claim Multiple Dwellings Relief, which worked out the tax on the average price per dwelling. It cannot be claimed for purchases that complete or are substantially performed on or after 1 June 2024, unless contracts were exchanged on or before 6 March 2024 (HMRC, SDLT reliefs). Mixed-use status is not a relief: it depends only on what you are buying. The 6-or-more-dwellings rule above still applies.

If you're planning a mixed-use claim

Sources and methodology

The rules above come from GOV.UK's rates pages, Finance Act 2003 sections 55 and 116 and Schedule 10, HMRC's Stamp Duty Land Tax Manual and the published judgments listed below. The worked example uses the rates in force since 1 April 2025, which still apply in 2026/27. The 28 October 2026 Budget left the residential rates, the 5% higher rates for additional dwellings and the non-residential and mixed-use rates (0% to £150,000, 2% to £250,000 and 5% above) unchanged. This page is educational only — for any actual mixed-use claim, instruct a specialist SDLT solicitor or tax adviser. The methodology page explains how pages are researched and reviewed.

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.