Your inputs
What this means
Compare the break-even point with the deal length, not just the monthly saving. A cheaper rate is not automatically a better decision if the switch costs eat most of the benefit.
Professional read
The repayment term and balance stay the same under both options so the comparison is rate-and-fee focused.
Comparing only the monthly payment and ignoring arrangement fees, cashback, legal costs and ERCs.
Once break-even looks acceptable, compare the lender features that matter next: overpayment allowance, portability and future ERC structure.
Tracker deals, fee-added-to-loan cases, or major planned overpayments need a more customised comparison than this first-pass tool.
Cost stack
| Line | Amount |
|---|
Worked examples — see the math on real numbers
When remortgaging early to a lower rate is worth the Early Repayment Charge.
Anita — 2 years into a 5-year fix at 5.5%
| Outstanding mortgage | £185,000 |
| Current rate | 5.5% (3 years remaining on fix) |
| New rate available | 4.0% 5-year fix |
| Early Repayment Charge (ERC) | 3% of balance = £5,550 |
| Remortgage fees (arrangement + legal) | £1,800 |
The math:
- Monthly saving from rate cut: 1.5% on £185,000 = £2,775/year ≈ £230/month
- Annual saving over remaining 3 years of old fix: £8,325
- Total costs to switch: £5,550 ERC + £1,800 fees = £7,350
- Break-even point: £7,350 ÷ £230/month = 32 months
- Time remaining on current fix: 36 months
Result: Anita breaks even at month 32 of a 36-month savings window — barely worth it. If the new fixed period extends past her old fix end-date, savings continue beyond break-even. Generally: ERCs >2.5% rarely justify early switching unless rate cut is 1.5%+.
Mark — 4 years into a 5-year fix, mortgage nearly ending
| Outstanding mortgage | £140,000 |
| Current rate | 6.0% |
| New rate available | 4.3% |
| ERC | 1% of balance = £1,400 (low because near end of fix) |
| Remortgage fees | £1,500 |
The math:
- Monthly saving: 1.7% × £140,000 = £2,380/year = £198/month
- Total switching cost: £1,400 + £1,500 = £2,900
- Break-even: £2,900 ÷ £198 = 14.6 months
- Time to natural fix end: 12 months
- Plus any new fix locks in lower rate going forward
Result: Mark recovers his switching costs in 15 months — slightly longer than the time to natural expiry, BUT the new 5-year fix at 4.3% protects against further rises and removes uncertainty. The decision becomes about rate prediction, not just immediate maths.
Figures use 2026/27 UK tax-year rates and thresholds. Always verify against your specific payslip or tax statement before acting.
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Every page is reviewed against the editorial standards, written from primary sources, sourced openly, and corrected publicly. No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.