Investment trusts are closed-ended companies whose shares trade on a stock market; the money they manage changes only when they issue or buy back shares. ETFs are open-ended funds whose shares are created or redeemed as money flows in and out. Three structural differences follow: (1) a trust's share price can sit well above or below the value of its assets, while an ETF's price normally stays close to its asset value; (2) trusts can borrow to invest (gearing), while UCITS ETFs may borrow only up to 10% of their value, temporarily; (3) trusts can keep back up to 15% of their income each year to smooth dividends, while ETFs pass on what they receive. There is also a cost difference: buying trust shares normally costs 0.5% stamp duty, while buying ETF shares does not.
The structural difference: closed-ended vs open-ended
| Investment trust | ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | A company approved by HMRC as an investment trust, with shares admitted to trading on a regulated market | An open-ended fund, usually a UCITS fund domiciled in Ireland or Luxembourg |
| Shares in issue | Change only when the trust issues new shares or buys them back | Created or redeemed as investors put money in or take it out |
| Price | Set by buyers and sellers; can trade at a discount or premium to net asset value | Creation and redemption normally keep the price close to net asset value |
| Borrowing | Can borrow to invest, within limits in its own articles | UCITS funds may borrow only up to 10% of their value, and only temporarily |
| Income | May keep up to 15% of income a year in a revenue reserve | Distributes or reinvests the income it receives |
| Management | Mostly actively managed, with a board of directors | Mostly index trackers; some active ETFs exist |
| Stamp duty when you buy | 0.5% stamp duty reserve tax (UK companies) | None (ETF shares are exempt) |
Ongoing charges vary widely in both groups. Broad index ETFs are generally the cheapest; compare each investment trust's ongoing charge on the AIC's site before buying.
The closed-ended advantage
An open-ended fund has to pay out cash when investors sell. If many sell at once and the fund owns assets that are slow to sell, such as commercial property, it may have to sell in a hurry or suspend dealing. In March 2020, for example, several open-ended commercial property funds suspended dealing because their valuers could not value the buildings with certainty, as the FCA noted at the time.
An investment trust does not face this problem: if you want to sell, you sell your shares to another investor on the market and the manager keeps the assets. That makes the structure suited to:
- Commercial property, where buildings can take months to sell.
- Infrastructure, such as wind farms, schools and hospitals, with long-lived, hard-to-sell assets.
- Private equity and other unlisted companies. UCITS funds can put no more than 10% of their assets into securities that are not traded on an eligible market.
- Smaller and frontier markets, where trading can be thin.
The cost of this stability is that the strain shows up in the share price instead: a trust's discount can widen sharply when investors want to sell.
Gearing: the trust's lever (and risk)
Investment trusts can borrow money to invest. Take a trust with £100 million of shareholders' money that borrows £20 million and invests £120 million. If its investments rise 10%, they are worth £132 million; after repaying the £20 million loan, shareholders have £112 million, a 12% gain. If the investments fall 10%, to £108 million, shareholders have £88 million, a 12% loss. Gearing magnifies gains and losses, before the cost of the borrowing.
Levels vary from none to substantial, and boards can change them. The AIC publishes each member company's current gearing, and the trust's factsheet shows it too.
Dividend reserves: the smoothing advantage
An investment trust may keep back up to 15% of its income each year in a revenue reserve, and draw on it in years when its income falls. That is how some trusts have built very long records: on the AIC's list dated 23 September 2026, 21 trusts had raised their dividend for 20 or more years in a row, and ten for more than 50 years. See our dividend heroes page.
ETFs and open-ended funds pass on the income they receive. If the companies an ETF holds cut their dividends by 30%, its distributions fall by about the same amount.
Worked example: when the discount moves
An illustrative trust and an ETF in a falling market
These figures are invented to show the mechanics; they are not the record of any real trust or fund.
| Trust's net asset value per share: start of year | £100 |
| Trust's share price: start of year (5% discount) | £95 |
| Net asset value per share: end of year (portfolio down 12%) | £88 |
| Share price: end of year (discount widened to 12%) | £77.44 |
| Return to the trust's shareholder | −18.5% |
| Comparable ETF over the same year (assumed) | −14% |
Here the trust's portfolio did better than the ETF (−12% against −14%), but its shareholders did worse (−18.5%) because the discount widened from 5% to 12%. The same effect works in reverse when a discount narrows.
The lesson: over a few years, a trust's return to shareholders can differ a lot from the return on its assets, depending on how the discount or premium moves.
When investment trusts can suit better
- Smoother income: people living on dividend income may value revenue reserves.
- Hard-to-sell assets: property, infrastructure and private equity sit more comfortably in a closed-ended structure.
- Buying at a discount: a trust at a 10% discount gives you £100 of assets for £90, although the discount may not narrow.
- Areas where you want active management: such as smaller companies or specialist markets.
When ETFs can suit better
- Tracking an index cheaply: broad index ETFs have some of the lowest charges available.
- Lower buying costs: no 0.5% stamp duty when you buy.
- Large trades: major ETFs are usually easy to trade in size.
- Predictability: the price normally stays close to the value of the assets, so there is no discount risk.
- Simplicity: no need to watch discounts, gearing or board decisions.
Tax treatment of investment trusts
For investors in the UK in 2026/27:
- Inside the trust: gains an approved investment trust makes on its investments are not chargeable gains, so the manager can trade without Capital Gains Tax inside the trust.
- Dividends: trust dividends are taxed as dividend income. Above the £500 dividend allowance, the rates are 10.75%, 35.75% and 39.35%.
- Capital Gains Tax: gains when you sell trust shares are taxed above the £3,000 annual exempt amount, at 18% or 24%.
- ISAs and SIPPs: dividends and gains are free of UK tax inside them.
- Stamp duty: buying investment trust shares normally costs 0.5% stamp duty reserve tax, because they are shares in UK companies. ETF shares are exempt.
- Foreign income: neither structure avoids withholding tax that other countries deduct from dividends paid to the trust or fund.
Sources
The rules and figures on this page were checked against these sources on 3 October 2026:
- Corporation Tax Act 2010, section 1158: the definition of an investment trust.
- Investment Trust (Approved Company) (Tax) Regulations 2011, regulation 19: the 15% limit on retained income.
- Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992, section 100: gains inside an investment trust are not chargeable gains.
- FCA Handbook, COLL 5.5 and COLL 5.2: UCITS borrowing limited to 10% of the fund, on a temporary basis, and no more than 10% in securities not traded on an eligible market.
- FCA: statement on property fund suspensions (March 2020).
- GOV.UK: tax when you buy shares and HMRC STSM101065: 0.5% stamp duty reserve tax on UK company shares, and the exemption for exchange traded funds.
- GOV.UK: tax on dividends and Capital Gains Tax rates: the 2026/27 rates and allowances.
- The AIC: dividend heroes: the list with data as at 23 September 2026.
The gearing and discount examples are this page's own arithmetic. The methodology page explains how pages are checked.
Related guides
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.