Skip to main content
Behavioural finance

Recency bias in fund picking

Fund lists on investment platforms are often sorted by recent returns, which makes it easy to buy whatever has just done well. Recency bias is the tendency to give recent results too much weight when judging what will happen next. Research on fund performance shows that top-ranked funds rarely stay at the top, and studies of investor returns show that buying after strong performance and selling after weak performance costs money. This page explains the evidence, why recent returns are a weak guide, and a worked example with stated assumptions.

By · Reviewed
Educational only. Past performance is not a guide to future returns. Funds named on this page are examples, not recommendations, and charges change; check the provider’s current documents. Not financial advice.

What recency bias is

People tend to give recent information more weight than it deserves when predicting what comes next. A fund that returned 35% last year feels “good”, one that returned 5% feels “average”, and one that lost 5% feels “bad”, so the instinct is to buy the 35% performer.

Over short periods, though, a fund’s return is influenced by many things other than skill:

Buying on the strength of last year’s return often means buying after prices have already risen.

What the evidence shows

S&P’s persistence scorecards

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes SPIVA scorecards comparing active funds with indices, and separate persistence scorecards that track whether top-ranked funds stay near the top. Its Europe persistence scorecard for year-end 2025, which covers UK equity fund categories among others, concludes that top-performing funds across asset classes generally failed to keep their top-quartile status from one period to the next. The detailed tables show the share of funds staying in the top quartile or top half over consecutive periods.

Morningstar’s “Mind the Gap” study

Morningstar compares two returns for funds:

The difference reflects the timing of investors’ purchases and sales. Morningstar’s 2025 study of US mutual funds and ETFs found that the average dollar invested earned 7.0% a year over the ten years to the end of 2024, about 1.2 percentage points a year less than the funds’ aggregate total return of 8.2%. Morningstar found that funds with more volatile cash flows, a sign of more trading by investors, tended to have larger gaps. The study covers US funds; the site’s page on the behavioural gap discusses how far such findings carry over to the UK.

How fund lists can encourage it

Platform fund lists and newspaper tables are often arranged by:

All of these naturally highlight whatever has done well recently.

Recent example: the rotation of 2020 to 2022

The years around the pandemic show how quickly leadership can change. In 2020 and 2021, growth and technology-focused funds and investment trusts were among the best performers and attracted large inflows. In 2022, as inflation and interest rates rose, many of the same funds fell sharply, while energy and value-oriented funds, which had lagged for years, were among the leaders. Investors who bought the previous period’s winners near their peak experienced large falls, and those who sold the lagging styles before 2022 missed their recovery. Exact figures depend on the fund and dates chosen.

By the time a fund or sector tops the tables, the news that drove its performance is usually already reflected in prices.

Why recent results feel convincing

Can manager skill be identified?

Academic research suggests that some managers do have skill, but that it is hard to identify in advance from returns alone:

Why many investors use index funds

Low-cost index funds and ETFs, such as Vanguard FTSE All-World (VWRL or VWRP), iShares Core S&P 500 (CSPX) and iShares Core MSCI World (SWDA), are widely held by UK investors. Compared with choosing funds on recent performance, an index fund:

Index funds have their own trade-offs: they hold whatever the index holds, so a market-weighted global fund is heavily weighted to the US and to the largest companies, and they never beat their index before costs.

Checks some investors use when choosing active funds

For investors who use active funds for some or all of their portfolio, these checks look beyond recent performance:

1. Charges

Some investors set a ceiling on ongoing charges and look for a specific reason before going above it, because the charge is deducted every year whatever the fund returns.

2. A long record under the same manager

If the manager changes, the previous record tells you less. A long record under the current manager is more informative, but even ten years is a small sample.

3. Process rather than results

Is the fund’s approach clear and consistent, or does the explanation seem to have been written backwards from recent results?

4. Awareness of style cycles

Some investors deliberately look at styles or sectors after a period of underperformance, the opposite of buying on recent returns. A style that has lagged can go on lagging, so this is not a guarantee either.

5. Spreading money across managers

Holding several funds reduces the effect of any one fund’s poor spell, but the more funds are held, the more the combination tends to resemble the market, at a higher cost than an index fund.

Questions that help spot recency bias

Worked example: charges and timing

This example is hypothetical. Two investors each pay £500 a month into an ISA for 30 years (£180,000 in total), and the market returns 7% a year before charges throughout. Returns are compounded monthly and tax is ignored inside the ISA.

Investor A: switches to recent winners

Investor B: holds one global index fund

The difference

Investor B ends up about £192,000 better off. With 1.0% charges but no timing gap (a 6.0% net return), Investor A would have about £502,300, so roughly £101,000 of the difference comes from the timing assumption and roughly £91,000 from the difference in charges. The result is sensitive to the assumptions: an active fund that outperformed its index after charges would narrow the gap, and a larger timing gap would widen it.

Frequently asked questions

What about funds with long records of outperformance?

They exist but are rare, and even well-known long-term outperformers have gone through extended weak periods. The difficulty is identifying them before the outperformance, not after it. By the time a manager is famous, the fund may be large, popular and more expensive.

What if funds were bought because of recent performance?

The original reason for buying is in the past. What matters is how the fund compares from here on with the alternatives, on cost and approach. Outside an ISA or SIPP, selling can create a capital gain for CGT, and some funds or platforms charge for dealing.

Is any recent information useful?

Some is. A manager change, a change of strategy, a sharp rise in charges or unusual losses compared with similar funds can all be reasons to look more closely. Strong recent performance on its own is a much weaker signal.

What about thematic funds such as AI, clean energy or biotech?

Thematic funds are often launched after a theme has already performed well, when investor interest is high. They are usually concentrated in one area, so they can rise and fall much more than a broad market fund, and their past returns are a particularly weak guide to the future. Some investors who want exposure to a theme keep it to a small part of their portfolio.

Sources

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.