ETF securities lending revenue — the hidden positive cost driver
An ETF you bought to "hold the index" doesn't sit still. Behind the scenes, many funds lend some of their holdings to banks and brokers, often to cover short sales, and earn fee income that offsets part of the fund's costs. Here's how it works, what the risk is, and how the income is split between the fund and the lending agent, with examples from providers' own documents.
What securities lending actually is
A borrower, usually a bank or broker acting for itself or for clients such as short-sellers, needs to borrow particular shares or bonds for a while. It may want to sell them short, settle a trade that would otherwise fail, or hedge another position. It goes to a lending agent, often a custodian bank or the fund manager's own lending desk, to borrow them.
The lending agent matches that demand with supply from long-term holders that do not need the securities in their own account every day. Index funds and ETFs are natural lenders: they hold large positions for long periods and already have a custodian in place.
In a typical loan, legal title to the securities passes to the borrower, who pays a fee that depends on how much demand there is for those particular securities, and provides collateral worth more than the securities lent, in cash or other securities. The collateral is revalued daily and topped up if the value of the loan rises. When the loan ends, the borrower returns equivalent securities and gets the collateral back. The fee income is shared between the fund and the lending agent, on terms disclosed in the fund's documents.
How much revenue does it generate?
It depends on demand to borrow what the fund holds. Broad funds of large, easy-to-borrow shares usually earn little relative to their assets; funds holding securities that are in demand, such as some smaller-company or emerging-market shares, can earn more. Bond funds generally earn less than equity funds. The amounts change from year to year.
Lending income is not deducted from the ongoing charges figure (OCF). It shows up instead in the fund's return, and so in its tracking difference against the index: a fund with a 0.20% OCF that earned net lending income of 0.05% of its assets in a year would, other things equal, trail its index by about 0.15% rather than 0.20% that year.
As an example of an actual figure, the iShares Core MSCI EM IMI UCITS ETF's fund page shows a securities lending return of 0.12% for the year from 30 June 2025 to 30 June 2026, with an average of 11.82% of the fund's assets on loan. An emerging-markets fund like this is at the higher end; broad developed-market funds usually earn less.
The revenue split — this is where providers differ
Under the European guidelines that Irish and Luxembourg UCITS follow, all revenue from securities lending, net of direct and indirect operational costs, must be returned to the fund, and the prospectus must disclose what costs and fees can be deducted. Managers set different arrangements within that rule. Two examples from the providers' own documents:
| Provider (fund range) | Split of lending income | Source |
|---|---|---|
| iShares UCITS ETFs (BlackRock) | 62.5% to the fund; 37.5% to BlackRock, which bears all the operational costs of lending | iShares fund pages |
| Vanguard Funds plc (Vanguard's Irish UCITS ETFs) | About 91% to 93% to the fund in the year to 30 June 2025, with the rest as the lending agent's fee, from which the agent pays the programme's operational costs | Vanguard Funds plc annual report, 30 June 2025 |
Arrangements can change and may vary between funds. Each fund's prospectus and annual report set out its own policy and the actual split.
A higher share for the fund means more of whatever income is earned reaches investors. But the split is only half the picture: how much the fund lends, and how much demand there is for its holdings, decide how much income there is to share. A fund that keeps a smaller share of a larger income can end up with more than one that keeps a larger share of a small income.
The risk side — counterparty risk + collateral
The main risk is that a borrower fails to return the securities and the collateral turns out to be worth less than it would cost to buy them back. The protections come from regulation and from each programme's own rules:
- Over-collateralisation: collateral is worth more than the securities lent. For iShares UCITS ETFs, for example, collateral ranges from 102.5% to 112% of the loan's value depending on the type of loan and collateral. It is revalued daily, and more is called for if the value of the loan rises.
- Collateral quality and diversification: under the ESMA guidelines, collateral should be highly liquid, valued at least daily, of high quality and sufficiently diversified.
- Collateral held separately: collateral is typically held by a third-party (tri-party) agent in segregated accounts, not by the borrower. Vanguard's 2025 annual report, for example, says its lending collateral is held by BNY Mellon as tri-party agent in segregated accounts.
- Ability to recall: the fund must be able to recall any security lent, or end any lending agreement, at any time.
If a borrower defaulted, the fund would use the collateral to buy back the securities; a loss would arise only if the collateral had fallen in value, or the securities had risen, by more than the margin of over-collateralisation before that could be done. The risk is small in normal conditions but not zero, and it is greatest in the kind of sudden market stress when borrowers are most likely to fail.
How to find the lending revenue for your ETF
- Fund annual report (usually the most detailed)
- Look for the "securities lending" note and the "securities financing transactions" disclosures
- These show the income earned, how it was split between the fund and the lending agent, the amount on loan, the main borrowers and the collateral held
- Prospectus: says whether the fund may lend, the maximum proportion of assets that may be on loan, and how income and costs are shared
- Fund web page: some providers, including iShares, show the split, collateral levels and the proportion of the fund on loan
- Tracking difference: lending income is one of the reasons a fund may trail its index by less than its OCF
Worked example — the cumulative effect
A hypothetical illustration. £50,000 is invested for 25 years in each of three otherwise identical index funds, all with a 0.07% OCF and a return of 6% a year before costs. Two of them earn gross lending income of 0.04% of assets a year:
- Fund A keeps 92% of its lending income (0.0368% a year). End value: about £212,900.
- Fund B keeps 62.5% of its lending income (0.025% a year). End value: about £212,300.
- Fund C does not lend. End value: about £211,100.
At these assumed levels, the difference between keeping 92% and 62.5% of lending income is about £600 over 25 years, and the difference between lending and not lending is up to about £1,800. The effect grows with the amount of lending income, which varies a lot between funds and over time.
ETFs that don't lend at all
Not every ETF lends. Examples of products that often do not:
- Funds whose managers choose not to: the prospectus or fund page states whether lending is permitted and whether it is used.
- Some ESG-focused funds: some managers restrict lending so they keep voting rights on all their holdings or avoid lending to short-sellers.
- Physically backed commodity ETCs (such as gold): these hold metal in a vault and are generally structured so that the metal is not lent.
- Swap-based (synthetic) ETFs: these get the index return through a swap and hold a substitute basket; whether that basket is lent depends on the fund.
What to look at when comparing funds
- Whether the fund lends, and the maximum proportion of its assets that can be on loan.
- How lending income is split between the fund and the lending agent or manager.
- The income actually earned, and the average amount on loan, from the annual report.
- The collateral policy: what types are accepted, how much over-collateralisation is required, and any protection against borrower default described in the fund documents.
- The fund's tracking difference over several years, which captures lending income along with all other costs and gains.
Securities lending is different from synthetic replication: lending happens within funds that own the securities, while synthetic ETFs use swaps. Both involve counterparty risk, but the mechanics are different.
Frequently asked questions
Does securities lending affect tracking error?
Slightly. Lending income adds to the fund's return relative to the index, and because it varies with demand it adds a little variability. It usually narrows the tracking difference (the gap between the fund's return and the index) by offsetting some of the fund's costs.
What collateral does the borrower post?
Typically cash, government bonds or liquid shares, meeting the programme's quality, liquidity and diversification rules. It is revalued daily and held in segregated accounts, usually with a third-party agent, not on the borrower's own balance sheet.
What proportion of fund assets is typically on loan?
It varies by fund and over time. For example, the iShares Core MSCI EM IMI UCITS ETF's web page shows an average of 11.82% of the fund on loan in the year to 30 June 2026, with a maximum of 13.40%. Annual reports show the figures for each fund.
Can a fund lend out all of its holdings?
The fund's prospectus sets the maximum proportion that can be on loan, and the fund must be able to recall securities at any time. In practice, the amount on loan is also limited by how much demand there is to borrow each holding.
What happens to voting rights when shares are on loan?
ETF investors do not vote the underlying shares themselves; the fund manager votes, or not, on the fund's behalf. When shares are on loan, the voting rights pass to the borrower with the shares, so a manager that wants to vote has to recall them before the relevant record date. Many managers publish their voting and recall policies.
Related guides
- Synthetic vs physical ETF replication
- Tracking difference vs tracking error
- ETF fund domicile — Ireland vs Luxembourg
- ETF cost comparison calculator
- Why your tracker isn't matching the index
- All UK Tax Drag ETF tools and guides
Sources
- ESMA — Guidelines on ETFs and other UCITS issues (ESMA/2014/937): efficient portfolio management, revenues and collateral
- iShares — Core MSCI EM IMI UCITS ETF fund page (securities lending split, collateral, amount on loan)
- Vanguard Funds plc — annual report, 30 June 2025 (securities lending income and split)
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.