Sunk cost fallacy in UK property decisions
“We paid £450,000 for it, so we won’t sell for less.” The sunk cost fallacy is the tendency to let money already spent, which cannot be recovered, influence decisions about the future. In property the sums are large, the purchase price is never forgotten, and the home carries emotional weight, so the bias is easy to fall into. This page explains how it works, the related biases, worked examples with illustrative figures, and forward-looking questions that set the purchase price aside.
What the sunk cost fallacy is
A sunk cost is money that has already been spent and cannot be recovered, whatever you decide next. In economic terms it is irrelevant to future decisions: only future costs and benefits differ between the options.
People often give sunk costs weight anyway. “I paid for the concert ticket, so I’ll go even though I feel ill.” “I’ve spent £5,000 repairing this car, so I’d better fix the next fault too.” “We paid £450,000 for this house, so we can’t accept £410,000.”
In each case the earlier payment is gone whatever happens next. What matters is which option is best from here: the value of resting against the concert, the cost of the next repair against a replacement car, and what the house is worth today against the alternatives.
Why property is especially prone to it
- Large sums: a 10% fall on a £400,000 home is £40,000, which feels like a very large loss.
- A remembered price: the purchase price is documented and easy to recall, unlike the cost of many other assets.
- A judgement on the purchase: selling for less than was paid can feel like admitting the purchase was a mistake.
- The home as part of life: selling can mean leaving a family home, not just completing a transaction.
- No pressure to decide: property is not priced every day in the way shares are, so it is easy to wait.
The result can be staying in a home that no longer suits, or turning down reasonable offers, because the price is below what was paid.
How the reasoning tends to run
- “We paid £450,000.”
- “The agents think it would sell for about £410,000 today.”
- “That’s a £40,000 loss.”
- “We won’t sell at a loss; we’ll wait for prices to recover.”
- Time passes, and the reasons for wanting to move continue.
The fall in value happened when the market price fell; selling does not create it, and not selling does not undo it. Either way the household owns something worth about £410,000 today. The question is whether that £410,000 is best kept in this home or used differently.
Forward-looking questions for a property decision
1. What is the home worth today?
- Agents’ valuations, bearing in mind that agents competing for an instruction may suggest a high figure
- Sold prices of similar homes nearby, which HM Land Registry publishes (sold prices, not asking prices)
- How quickly similar homes are selling
2. What are the alternatives?
Suppose the home were sold today, the mortgage repaid and the remaining equity held as cash. Would that money go into:
- a different home, in a different area or of a different size?
- renting, with the rest saved or invested?
- a smaller home, releasing cash for retirement?
If an alternative would suit the household better, the purchase price is not a reason to stay. If this home is still the best use of the money, staying makes sense regardless of the purchase price.
3. Which costs actually differ between the options?
Some costs arise whichever option is chosen, such as the costs of owning a home somewhere. The ones that matter are those that differ:
- Moving costs: estate agent and legal fees, removals, and Stamp Duty Land Tax on the next purchase in England and Northern Ireland (Land and Buildings Transaction Tax in Scotland, Land Transaction Tax in Wales). For a main home in England bought for £600,000, SDLT at the current rates is £20,000. These costs are a genuine, forward-looking reason to think carefully before moving.
- Running costs: council tax, energy, insurance and maintenance may be higher or lower in the alternative.
- Mortgage costs: the size and rate of the loan needed for each option.
- Returns on released cash: if an option frees up equity, what that money could earn or pay for instead.
The purchase price appears nowhere in this list.
A related bias: anchoring
Anchoring is the tendency to fix on a reference number and judge everything else against it. For property, the purchase price often becomes the anchor. Signs include:
- “It must be worth at least £450,000, because that’s what we paid.”
- “We won’t accept less than £420,000” — where the figure comes from the purchase price rather than recent sales.
- “When prices recover it will be worth £500,000.”
A buyer will pay what the market supports today, which has no necessary link to what the current owner paid.
Examples with illustrative figures
Example 1: moving up after prices have fallen
The Browns bought a two-bedroom flat for £520,000 in 2022. Suppose it is now worth £470,000, with £360,000 left on the mortgage, so their equity is £110,000. They want a three-bedroom house costing £600,000.
- Moving now: the gap between the two prices is £130,000. With £110,000 of equity, they would need a mortgage of about £490,000, plus moving costs.
- If both prices rise 10% while they wait: the flat is worth £517,000 (equity about £157,000) and the house £660,000. The gap widens to £143,000, and they would need to borrow about £503,000, plus higher SDLT.
- If both fall 5%: the flat is worth £446,500 and the house £570,000, and the gap narrows to £123,500.
For someone selling one home to buy another in the same market, the gap between the two prices matters more than the purchase price of the flat. Waiting for the flat to “get back to £520,000” does not help if the house they want rises too. Ignoring repayments made in the meantime, this is a simplified illustration; the real decision also depends on mortgage rates, how well the flat suits the family, and the timing of a move.
Example 2: downsizing before retirement
The Patels, both 65, own a four-bedroom house bought for £180,000 in 1998 and now worth £850,000, with no mortgage. Their children have left home. A £500,000 two-bedroom home would release £350,000 before costs; SDLT on a £500,000 main home in England is £15,000, and there would be agents’ and legal fees too. Because it has been their only home throughout, Private Residence Relief normally means no Capital Gains Tax on the gain.
Reasons they give for staying include:
- “We’ve lived here for 28 years.” Attachment to a home, friends and neighbourhood is a real, forward-looking reason.
- “We paid £180,000, so we’ve made £670,000.” That gain exists whether they move or not, so it does not favour either option.
- “Prices might keep rising.” They might, or might not; a smaller home would also move with the market.
The decision turns on whether the released money and a smaller home would improve their retirement more than staying would, allowing for costs and for what the house means to them. The purchase price does not help answer that.
Example 3: dividing a home on divorce
A couple bought a home for £480,000 in 2020. It is now valued at £460,000. Options include selling and dividing the proceeds, or one buying out the other’s share at a price based on the current value.
One partner argues: “We paid £480,000, so the valuation is too low; we should wait until it gets back to that.” But the current value is what the home would sell for now, and it is the natural starting point for any buyout. The purchase price does not change what the home is worth. How assets are divided on divorce depends on much more than the house, and legal advice is usually part of the process.
Techniques for setting the purchase price aside
1. The “would we rent it?” test
Imagine renting this home on the open market instead of owning it. Would you choose it, today, over the alternatives available? If not, that suggests the home no longer suits, whatever it cost.
2. The cash test
If you were handed the home’s current value in cash, would you use it to buy this same home? If yes, staying is consistent with what you value. If you would buy something else, the reasons for staying are worth examining.
3. The friend test
Imagine a friend in the same position says: “We bought for £450,000, it’s worth £410,000, we want to move but can’t face selling for less than we paid.” Most people can see more easily in someone else’s case that the £40,000 fall has already happened.
4. Setting a time limit
If waiting for prices to recover is a considered choice, some people set a date and a price: “If it hasn’t reached £X by a set date, we’ll decide again on today’s value.” That turns an open-ended wait into a decision with a review point.
When staying is the better choice
The sunk cost fallacy is about the reasoning, not the outcome. There are good forward-looking reasons to stay in a home that is worth less than was paid:
- It still suits the household, and the alternatives would be no better.
- Moving costs such as SDLT and fees would outweigh the benefit of moving.
- Negative equity or tight finances make moving difficult or impossible for now.
- Personal reasons, such as schools, work, care or community ties.
- Specific local information, such as planned transport links, though these may already be reflected in prices.
The test is whether the reasons look forward (what suits the household from here) or backward (what was paid).
Related biases
The endowment effect
People tend to value things they own more highly than identical things they do not. In a well-known experiment by Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler (1990), people given a mug asked for roughly twice as much to sell it as others were willing to pay to buy one. With property, it can show up as refusing an offer you would not pay yourself for the same home.
Loss aversion
Losses tend to feel about twice as strong as equivalent gains (see the loss aversion guide), so selling below the purchase price can feel especially painful.
Status quo bias
Keeping things as they are takes less effort than change. Selling, finding a new home and moving are demanding, so staying put is the default even when a change would suit better.
Frequently asked questions
What if prices do recover?
They might. But a recovery helps a seller who is buying in the same market only if their home rises more than the one they want to buy, and waiting has its own costs if the current home does not suit. A view that prices will recover is a forecast, and like any forecast it can be wrong.
Does inflation change the picture?
Inflation reduces the buying power of both property and cash. It does not change the basic point that the purchase price is in the past; what matters is how the options compare from here.
What if my partner is anchored to the purchase price?
It can help to separate the financial comparison from the emotional reasons, which are legitimate in their own right, and to look at recent sold prices together. Some couples find an independent third party, such as a financial planner, helps keep the conversation focused on the options.
Should estate agents be told what we paid?
The agent acts for the seller, but the price achieved depends on buyers, who can usually see past sale prices on public records anyway. Asking agents to justify their valuation with recent comparable sales keeps the focus on current value.
What if we are in negative equity?
Negative equity means the sale price would not cover the mortgage, so selling would need extra cash or the lender’s agreement. That is a real constraint rather than a sunk cost, and it can make waiting the only practical option. Lenders can explain options such as porting the mortgage, and free debt advice is available through MoneyHelper.
Does the same bias affect investments?
Yes. “I won’t sell this share until it gets back to what I paid” is the same reasoning. A share’s price is set by the market’s view of its future, not by what any one investor paid for it.
Sources
- GOV.UK — Stamp Duty Land Tax: residential property rates
- GOV.UK — Tax when you sell your home (Private Residence Relief)
- GOV.UK — Search property information from HM Land Registry
- Kahneman, D., Knetsch, J. and Thaler, R. (1990), “Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem”, Journal of Political Economy 98(6)
- Arkes, H. and Blumer, C. (1985), “The psychology of sunk cost”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 35(1)
Related guides
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.