Loss aversion in retirement drawdown
Loss aversion is the tendency to feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size; in Tversky and Kahneman’s 1992 estimates, losses weighed roughly twice as heavily as gains. For someone drawing an income from their pension, that instinct matters more than it does during working life, because selling investments after a fall to “stop the losses” can turn a temporary fall into a permanent one. This page explains the research, why drawdown is different, the structures some retirees use to reduce the pressure to sell, and a worked example with illustrative numbers.
What loss aversion means
A classic illustration is a coin toss: heads you win £150, tails you lose £100. On average the bet is favourable (an expected gain of £25 a toss), yet many people turn it down, because the prospect of losing £100 feels worse than the prospect of winning £150 feels good.
Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky set out prospect theory in 1979, describing how people judge outcomes as gains and losses from a reference point, with losses looming larger. In their 1992 follow-up paper on cumulative prospect theory, their median estimate of the loss-aversion coefficient was 2.25: in their experiments, a loss weighed a little more than twice as much as a gain of the same size. Later studies have found a wide range of estimates, and the effect varies from person to person and situation to situation, but the basic asymmetry is one of the most widely replicated findings in behavioural economics.
For investors, the practical consequence is that a fall in value creates a strong urge to act — often to sell, to “stop the losses” — even when nothing about the person’s plans or needs has changed.
Why drawdown makes it matter more
While someone is working and contributing, a fall in prices means new contributions buy more units, and there is usually time for prices to recover before the money is needed. In drawdown the position is different:
- Money is being taken out. Withdrawals made after a fall mean selling more units to raise the same income, and those units cannot recover.
- Sequence of returns risk: two retirees with the same average return can end up with very different outcomes if one suffers large falls early in retirement, while withdrawals are being taken, and the other suffers them later.
- Selling everything after a fall and staying out of the market turns a paper fall into a permanent loss, and it means missing any recovery.
- There is no salary to rebuild the pot, which can make falls feel more threatening.
The same market fall can therefore have a much larger effect on a retiree who sells at the low point than on a younger saver who keeps contributing.
What recent market falls show
Two recent episodes illustrate the pressures, without precise figures, which depend on the index, currency and dates used:
- Early 2020: global share prices fell very sharply over a few weeks as the pandemic spread, then recovered strongly over the following months. Investors who sold near the low and waited for calmer conditions before buying back could miss much of that recovery.
- 2022: rising interest rates hit bonds and shares at the same time, so balanced portfolios that normally rely on bonds to cushion share falls had a poor year. Long-dated UK gilts and index-linked gilts fell especially heavily. For example, the iShares £ Index-Linked Gilts ETF’s factsheet shows a fall of about 35% in calendar year 2022.
Not every fall is followed by a quick recovery. A single country’s share market can stay below a previous peak for many years — Japan’s did for decades after 1989 — which is one reason diversification and the length of time before money is needed both matter.
How the pattern tends to play out
Behavioural finance research describes a recognisable pattern, although timings vary and not every investor follows it:
- Early in a fall, most investors hold and treat it as a normal correction.
- As losses and news coverage build, people check their portfolios more often, which makes the losses more salient.
- At the point of greatest fear, the wish to avoid further losses can outweigh the plan, and some investors sell.
- If prices recover, the investor holding cash faces a second decision — when to buy back — and each rise can make buying back feel harder.
Richard Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi called a related effect “myopic loss aversion”: the more often people evaluate their investments, the more losses they see, and the less risk they are willing to hold.
Why knowing about it is not always enough
Many investors know that markets have historically recovered from falls, but loss aversion is an emotional response, not a gap in knowledge. Other influences add to it:
- “This time is different”: every fall comes with persuasive reasons to think it will last — a banking crisis, a pandemic, an inflation shock.
- Negative news: coverage during a fall tends to be dominated by bad news.
- Other people: hearing that friends or family have sold can reinforce the urge to follow.
- Erosion of confidence: each further fall makes the original plan feel less trustworthy.
This is why much of the practical discussion focuses on arrangements made in advance, rather than on willpower during a fall.
Structures some retirees use
The approaches below are common ways of reducing the need or temptation to sell after a fall. Each has costs and trade-offs, and none suits everyone.
1. A cash buffer
Some retirees keep a year or more of planned withdrawals in cash, a money market fund or short-dated gilts, and take income from that buffer after a fall instead of selling shares at lower prices. The buffer is topped up from investments when markets are higher.
- What it helps with: it reduces forced selling during a fall and gives a period in which prices may recover.
- Trade-offs: cash has historically returned less than shares over long periods and can lose value after inflation, so a large buffer can reduce long-run returns. A buffer also needs rules about when to use it and when to refill it.
- Illustration: with planned withdrawals of £30,000 a year, a two-year buffer is £60,000 and a three-year buffer £90,000.
2. A guaranteed income floor
Another approach is to cover essential spending from guaranteed income, so that investment falls affect only discretionary spending. The State Pension provides part of that floor for many people: the full new State Pension is £241.30 a week in 2026/27, and HM Treasury’s Pension Tax Allowance explainer gives £13,036.40 a year for 2027/28 (checked 29 October 2026). An annuity bought with part of a pension pot can add more guaranteed income, either level or rising each year.
- What it helps with: if essentials are covered, a fall in the drawdown pot is less likely to feel like a threat to basic living costs.
- Trade-offs: buying an annuity is normally irreversible; the money used is no longer available for flexible withdrawals or, usually, to pass on; and a level annuity loses buying power with inflation. Annuity rates depend on age, health, the type of annuity and interest rates at the time, and they differ between providers, so quotes are worth comparing. MoneyHelper has an annuity comparison tool.
3. Written rules decided in advance
Some investors write down, while markets are calm, how their money is invested and what they will do in different circumstances — sometimes called an investment policy statement. It might set out:
- a target mix, for example 60% shares and 40% bonds and cash
- when to rebalance, for example once a year or when the mix drifts by more than a set amount
- how withdrawals are taken, for example from the buffer first after a fall
- a waiting period before making any change prompted by market movements
A rule written in advance is a form of pre-commitment. Rebalancing back to a target mix after a fall in shares means selling some bonds or cash to buy shares, which is the opposite of what loss aversion prompts.
Guidance and advice
Free, impartial guidance is available from Pension Wise, part of MoneyHelper: people over 50 with a defined contribution pension can book an appointment to talk through their options. Guidance explains the options but does not recommend what to do.
A regulated financial adviser can give a personal recommendation, and one role an adviser can play is helping a client stick to an agreed plan during market falls. Advice has a cost, which varies by firm and by the service provided, so it helps to ask how charges are worked out and what ongoing service they cover. The FCA’s Financial Services Register shows whether a firm is authorised.
Questions worth thinking through in advance
- How much of essential spending is covered by guaranteed income, such as the State Pension, a defined benefit pension or an annuity?
- If shares fell by a third, where would the next year or two of withdrawals come from?
- What investment mix is intended, and what would prompt a change — a change in circumstances, or only a change in prices?
- How often is the portfolio checked, and does frequent checking make decisions harder?
- Is there someone to talk decisions through with before acting, whether a family member, a guidance service or an adviser?
Worked example: selling after a fall
This example uses hypothetical round numbers, not actual market data. Withdrawals, charges, interest on cash and bond price changes are left out so that the effect of the decision is clear. Sarah has a £500,000 drawdown pot: £300,000 in shares and £200,000 in bonds.
Scenario A: holds through the fall
- Shares fall 30%: £300,000 becomes £210,000, so the pot is £410,000 (down 18%).
- Share prices then recover to their starting level: the shares are worth £300,000 again.
- Pot after the recovery: £500,000.
Scenario B: sells all shares at the low and buys back later
- Sarah sells her shares at the low point for £210,000 and holds the money in cash.
- She buys back only after prices have risen 25% from the low, when they are at 87.5% of their starting level (0.70 × 1.25).
- Her £210,000 buys fewer units than she sold. When prices reach their starting level, those shares are worth £210,000 ÷ 0.875 = £240,000.
- Pot after the recovery: £240,000 + £200,000 = £440,000.
The difference
Selling and buying back later leaves Sarah £60,000 (12% of her starting pot) worse off than holding, even though prices ended where they began. If that £60,000 would otherwise have grown at an assumed 3% a year above inflation for 20 years, the gap in today’s money would be about £108,000 (£60,000 × 1.0320). If prices had instead kept falling after she sold, selling would have left her better off, which is why the decision feels so difficult at the time: nobody knows in advance which path prices will take.
Frequently asked questions
Is loss aversion always harmful?
No. Caution about losses can stop people taking risks they cannot afford, such as concentrating savings in one speculative investment. The difficulty is that the same instinct can prompt selling after a fall, when prices are lower, which locks in the loss.
What if a fall turns out to be permanent?
That is possible. Broad share markets have recovered from past crashes, but recoveries have sometimes taken many years, and a single country’s market can stay below its peak for decades. Past recoveries do not guarantee future ones. That uncertainty is one reason people diversify across countries and asset types and match investment risk to when money will be needed.
How can someone tell whether they are panicking or reassessing?
One test is whether anything about their own circumstances has changed — health, spending needs, other income, or how long the money needs to last. A change prompted only by recent price movements is more likely to be loss aversion at work. Writing down the reason for a change, and waiting before acting, can help separate the two.
Does checking a portfolio often make a difference?
Research on myopic loss aversion suggests it can. Prices move up and down from day to day, so frequent checking shows many more individual losses than an annual statement does, even when the long-run trend is up, and seeing more losses tends to make people less willing to hold risky assets.
Does the same bias affect property decisions?
Yes, although property cannot be sold in a panic as easily as shares. It can show up as reluctance to sell below the price originally paid, or to move from a family home even when circumstances have changed. See the page on the sunk cost fallacy in property decisions.
Sources
- Kahneman, D. and Tversky, A. (1979), “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk”, Econometrica 47(2)
- Tversky, A. and Kahneman, D. (1992), “Advances in prospect theory: Cumulative representation of uncertainty”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 5
- Benartzi, S. and Thaler, R. (1995), “Myopic Loss Aversion and the Equity Premium Puzzle”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 110(1)
- GOV.UK — The new State Pension: what you’ll get
- GOV.UK — Plan your retirement income (Pension Wise)
Related guides
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.