Tracking difference vs tracking error
Two different metrics with similar-sounding names. Tracking error tells you how noisy the fund-vs-index relationship is. Tracking difference tells you whether the fund actually kept up. For long-term ETF holders, tracking difference is usually the more telling of the two. Here's the clean distinction, with figures from a fund manager's audited annual report.
The clean distinction in one paragraph
Tracking difference (TD) = the gap between the fund's return and the index's return over a period. A positive TD means the fund beat the index; a negative TD means the fund trailed. It is usually quoted for a year, or as an annual average over 3 or 5 years.
Tracking error (TE) = the volatility (standard deviation) of the differences between the fund's return and the index's return, measured at regular intervals (often monthly or daily) and annualised. A high TE means the gap moves around a lot; a low TE means it is consistent. It says nothing about whether the gap is positive or negative.
Said differently: tracking difference is "did the fund keep up?"; tracking error is "did the fund keep up consistently?".
The mathematics, with numbers
Imagine a fund and its index over four quarters. Fund returns: +5%, +3%, −4%, +2%. Index returns: the same. Tracking difference = 0%; tracking error = 0%. Perfect replication.
Now imagine fund returns of +4%, +4%, −5%, +3% against index returns of +5%, +3%, −4%, +2%. The quarterly differences are −1, +1, −1 and +1 percentage points. Compounded, the fund returns about +5.8% for the year and the index about +5.9%, so the tracking difference is about −0.1%: the fund very nearly kept up. But the quarterly differences have a standard deviation of about 1 percentage point, which annualises (multiplying by the square root of 4) to a tracking error of about 2%. This fund kept up, but unevenly.
Finally, imagine fund returns of +4.7%, +2.7%, −4.3%, +1.7% against the same index. Each quarter the fund is exactly 0.3 points behind. Compounded, the fund returns about +4.65% against the index's +5.9%: a tracking difference of about −1.25%, with a tracking error of 0%, because the gap never varies. This fund fell behind by the same amount every quarter.
Over a long holding period, the second fund ends up close to the index despite the quarter-to-quarter noise, while the third falls further behind every year. That is why long-term holders usually look first at tracking difference.
What drives tracking difference
For a UK-listed UCITS ETF, tracking difference is roughly the sum of:
- OCF — the fund's ongoing charges, taken out of the fund's assets day by day. Often the largest single cost.
- Withholding tax differences — the tax deducted from dividends the fund receives, compared with what the index assumes. Many indices used as benchmarks are "net" indices that assume a set rate of withholding tax. For US shares, Vanguard's S&P 500 UCITS ETF, for example, bears 15% US withholding tax on dividends while its benchmark index assumes 30%, which helps the fund's return compared with the benchmark.
- Sampling — a fund that holds a representative sample of the index, rather than every member, will drift from it by some amount
- Cash and flows — cash held for dividends or dealing does not move with the index
- Securities lending income (a positive factor) — lending some holdings earns income that offsets part of the costs
- Transaction costs and, for hedged share classes, currency hedging — usually smaller, but real
Because of these offsetting effects, a fund's tracking difference is not simply minus its OCF. It can be smaller than the OCF, larger, or even positive, depending on the fund and the benchmark it is measured against.
What drives tracking error
Tracking error is about noise, not direction:
- Sampling — the more a fund samples rather than holding every index member, the noisier the fund-versus-index relationship
- Index changes — if the fund trades a little before or after the index changes, returns diverge for a few days
- Cash and flows — large inflows or outflows can cause short-term noise while cash is invested or raised
- Currency hedging for hedged share classes
- Securities lending income can add a little variability as well as its positive drift
- Valuation differences — for example, when a fund and its index value a holding differently
- For synthetic ETFs: the terms and resetting of the swap
Fully replicated funds tracking large, liquid indices tend to have very low tracking error; sampled funds, emerging markets and less liquid markets tend to have more. The table below shows examples.
Real numbers: tracking difference and tracking error for five UK-listed ETFs
From Vanguard Funds plc's audited annual report for the year to 30 June 2025. Tracking difference is the one-year fund return minus the index return, after charges. Realised tracking error is Vanguard's figure for the trailing 36 months, calculated gross of fees.
| ETF (share class) | Benchmark | Fund 1y | Index 1y | TD | TE (36m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vanguard FTSE 100 UCITS ETF (GBP Acc) | FTSE 100 | 11.13% | 11.26% | −0.13 | 0.021% |
| Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF (USD Acc) | FTSE All-World | 16.36% | 16.40% | −0.04 | 0.065% |
| Vanguard S&P 500 UCITS ETF (USD Acc) | S&P 500 (dividends net of 30% withholding tax) | 14.86% | 14.70% | +0.16 | 0.023% |
| Vanguard FTSE Emerging Markets UCITS ETF (USD Acc) | FTSE Emerging | 16.26% | 16.30% | −0.04 | 0.556% |
| Vanguard Global Aggregate Bond UCITS ETF (GBP-Hedged Acc) | Bloomberg Global Aggregate Float Adjusted and Scaled, GBP hedged | 5.80% | 5.90% | −0.10 | 0.125%* |
Past figures for one year only; they change every year. *Tracking error for this fund is reported on its USD-hedged accumulating share class. Vanguard attributes the emerging markets fund's higher tracking error to selling Russian holdings that had been valued at zero and were not in the benchmark.
Two things stand out. The S&P 500 fund beat its benchmark, largely because of the withholding tax difference described above. And the emerging markets fund had a one-year tracking difference similar to the global fund's, but a much higher tracking error: it kept up over the year, but less consistently.
How to read the numbers
- Compare tracking difference with the OCF: a tracking difference smaller than the OCF means other factors (such as securities lending or tax treatment) offset part of the cost; a larger one means other costs added to it.
- Compare like with like: tracking difference is most useful between funds tracking the same index, measured over the same period and in the same currency.
- Look at several years: one year can be affected by one-off events; an average over 3 to 5 years says more about the structure of a fund's costs.
- Check the benchmark: whether the index is measured before or after withholding tax changes what a "normal" tracking difference looks like.
- Read tracking error in context: a higher figure is expected for sampled, emerging-market and hedged funds, and a fund's prospectus states the tracking error it anticipates.
When each metric matters more
Tracking difference is the more direct measure for long-term holders, because what builds up over time is the cumulative gap between the fund's return and the index's.
Tracking error matters more over short periods, for example to someone holding for a few months or managing a portfolio against a benchmark, where how far the fund can stray from the index at any moment is the concern.
Both are backward-looking. Neither guarantees how a fund will track in future.
How to find these numbers
- Annual report — under the ESMA guidelines on ETFs and other UCITS issues, an index-tracking UCITS's annual report should state its tracking error at the end of the period, explain any divergence from the tracking error it anticipated, and disclose and explain its annual tracking difference.
- Prospectus — states the anticipated level of tracking error.
- Fund factsheet or web page — usually shows fund returns next to index returns for standard periods; the gap between them is the tracking difference.
- Independent ETF databases — some calculate tracking difference for funds tracking the same index, which makes comparison easier; check which share class and currency they use.
Frequently asked questions
Can tracking difference be positive?
Yes. Securities lending income, withholding tax paid at a lower rate than the benchmark assumes (as with the S&P 500 example above), or small timing effects can put a fund ahead of its index. Where the reason is structural, such as the tax difference, it can persist; where it is a one-off, it will not.
Is "tracking difference" the same as "alpha"?
They are related but used differently. Alpha usually refers to an active manager's performance against a benchmark, often after adjusting for risk. Tracking difference is the simpler gap between an index fund and its index, with no risk adjustment.
Why do some factsheets show tracking error but not tracking difference?
Factsheets vary in what they summarise. Under the ESMA guidelines, the annual report of an index-tracking UCITS should include both the tracking error and the annual tracking difference, with explanations. On a factsheet, the tracking difference can be worked out from the fund and index returns shown side by side.
Does tracking difference include OCF?
Yes. Fund returns are reported after the OCF has been taken out of the fund's assets, so the tracking difference already reflects it. For example, a tracking difference of −0.25% a year on a fund with a 0.07% OCF would mean that other factors cost a further 0.18% a year.
Is a fund with positive TD better than one with negative TD?
Over the period measured, it kept closer to (or ahead of) its index. But one year can reflect one-off effects, and funds measured against different benchmarks are not directly comparable. Averages over three to five years, for funds tracking the same index, are more informative.
Related guides
- Tracking error in the ETF metrics glossary
- Why your tracker isn't matching the index
- ETF cost comparison calculator
- Synthetic vs physical ETF replication
- ETF metrics glossary
Sources
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.