Skip to main content
Tax trap deep dive · 2026/27

EIS clawback — when the 30% income tax relief is withdrawn

The Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) gives 30% income tax relief on new shares in qualifying unquoted companies, so a £100,000 subscription can reduce the investor’s Income Tax bill by up to £30,000. The relief is conditional. It is reduced or withdrawn if the investor disposes of the shares within the 3-year qualifying period, receives value from the company, or becomes connected with it, or if the company stops meeting the scheme’s conditions. Some of those events are outside the investor’s control.

By · Reviewed

EIS income tax relief (30%) is reduced or withdrawn if a condition is broken before the termination date, normally 3 years after the shares are issued. The main triggers: (1) disposing of the shares: an arm’s-length sale reduces the relief by 30% of the sale proceeds, which removes all of it unless the shares are sold for less than was subscribed, and a gift withdraws all of it; (2) receiving value from the company, which reduces the relief by 30% of the value received; (3) becoming connected with the company; (4) the company ceasing to qualify. HMRC recovers the relief by an assessment for the tax year in which it was given, with interest from the following 31 January.

The basics — the EIS reliefs

EIS shares can carry up to five separate tax reliefs, each with its own conditions:

  1. Income tax relief at 30% of the amount subscribed for new shares, on up to £1 million a tax year (£2 million if at least £1 million of it is invested in knowledge-intensive companies). The relief reduces the Income Tax bill for the year and cannot be more than that bill.
  2. Capital Gains Tax disposal relief: a gain on shares sold after the 3-year period is free of CGT if income tax relief was given on them and has not been withdrawn. If the income tax relief was reduced, the exemption is restricted in proportion.
  3. CGT deferral relief: a gain on any other asset can be deferred by subscribing for EIS shares between 1 year before and 3 years after that disposal. The deferred gain comes back into charge when the EIS shares are disposed of.
  4. Loss relief: if the shares are sold at a loss, the loss (after deducting any income tax relief kept) can be set against income of that tax year or the previous one, or against capital gains.
  5. Inheritance Tax Business Relief: unquoted EIS shares usually qualify once held for 2 years. From 6 April 2026, 100% relief applies to the first £2.5 million of combined business and agricultural property and 50% above that. The shares stay in the estate; the relief reduces the value taxed.

The income tax relief depends on conditions that must keep being met until the termination date: the third anniversary of the share issue or, if the money was raised for a trade the company had not yet started, the third anniversary of the start of trading, if that is later. The clock runs from the issue date on the company’s EIS3 certificate, not the date the investor applied or paid.

What reduces or withdraws the relief

  1. Disposing of the shares before the termination date. On an arm’s-length sale, the relief is reduced by 30% of the sale proceeds, or withdrawn in full if that figure is more than the relief. A gift or any other disposal not at arm’s length withdraws all of it. A transfer to a spouse or civil partner the investor lives with is not treated this way, and nothing that happens on or after the investor’s death withdraws relief.
  2. The company stops qualifying. Several company conditions must be met from the share issue to the termination date, including carrying on a qualifying trade (excluded activities include dealing in land or shares, banking and other financial activities, legal and accountancy services, and property development) and not being a 51% subsidiary of, or controlled by, another company. If the company fails one of them, the relief is withdrawn even though the investor did nothing. Other conditions are tested only at the issue: the company must be unquoted with no arrangements to list, and its gross assets must not exceed the limit immediately before and after the issue (for most companies, £30 million before and £35 million after, for shares issued from 6 April 2026), so later growth or a later listing that was not arranged at the time does not breach them.
  3. The investor becomes connected with the company at any time from 2 years before the share issue (or the company’s incorporation, if later) to the termination date. An employee or a paid director is connected, subject to the “business angel” exception for directors described below, and so is anyone who, together with their associates, holds more than 30% of the ordinary share capital, the issued share capital or the voting power, or rights to more than 30% of the assets on a winding up.
  4. The investor receives value from the company from 12 months before the issue to the termination date: for example, the repayment of a loan the investor made before the issue, a loan from the company to the investor, or an asset bought from the company below market value. The relief is reduced by 30% of the value received (explained in detail below).
  5. Deferral relief is separate. If EIS shares were used to defer a gain on another asset, the deferred gain comes back into charge when those shares are disposed of, whenever that happens, or if the investor becomes non-resident within 3 years of the issue. That is a Capital Gains Tax charge on the old gain, not a withdrawal of the income tax relief.

The 28 October 2026 Budget announced technical changes in Finance Bill 2026-27 for shares issued on or after 6 April 2027: going over an EIS limit costs only the relief on the part above the limit, rather than all of it; SEIS shares can be issued on the same day as EIS shares or VCT investments; and one investor's late payment does not by itself remove other investors' relief. For VCT shares issued on or after 6 April 2026, relief withdrawn on a disposal is to be clawed back at the rate that applied when the shares were issued. The relief rates, including the 30% EIS rate, and the investment limits are unchanged (overview of tax legislation and rates, paragraph 1.36; checked 29 October 2026).

Worked clawback example — early sale at 2 years

Scenario: £50,000 EIS investment, sold for £80,000 after 2 years

The investor subscribes £50,000 for new shares, has at least £15,000 of Income Tax to set the relief against, pays Capital Gains Tax at the higher rate (24% in 2026/27) and has already used the £3,000 annual exempt amount. No gain was deferred into these shares.

At subscription (Year 0):

Cash subscribed£50,000
30% income tax relief claimed£15,000
Net cost after relief£35,000

At sale (Year 2, an arm’s-length sale):

Sale proceeds£80,000
Relief withdrawn: the smaller of the relief given (£15,000) and 30% of the proceeds (£24,000)−£15,000
Gain: £80,000 − £50,000 (no CGT exemption, because the shares were sold within 3 years)£30,000
CGT on the £30,000 gain at 24%−£7,200
Overall result: £80,000 − £50,000 − £7,200 (the £15,000 relief was given and then withdrawn)£22,800

The same shares sold for the same £80,000 after the termination date:

Sale proceeds£80,000
Income tax relief kept£15,000
CGT on the £30,000 gain (disposal relief: held 3 years, relief not withdrawn)£0
Overall result: £80,000 + £15,000 − £50,000£45,000

At the same price, the difference between the two outcomes is £22,200: the £15,000 of relief and the £7,200 of CGT. The timing matters only in relation to the termination date: a sale one day before it is treated exactly like a sale at 6 months, and there is no partial credit for time held.

A sale at a loss. If the Year-2 sale had raised only £30,000, 30% of the proceeds is £9,000, which is less than the £15,000 relief, so the relief is reduced by £9,000 and £6,000 is kept. For the loss calculation, the cost is reduced by the relief kept: £30,000 − (£50,000 − £6,000) gives an allowable loss of £14,000, which can be relieved against income or gains if the share loss relief conditions are met.

Receipts of value from the company

The receipt-of-value rules stop relief being given on money that flows straight back to the investor. They apply to value received from 12 months before the share issue to the termination date, and value received by the investor’s associates (such as a spouse, civil partner, parent or child) counts as well.

Examples of receipts of value in the legislation:

Some payments are not receipts of value: reasonable pay for services as a director, and payments for goods or services at no more than market value on normal credit terms, among others.

Receipts of insignificant valueA receipt is ignored if it is not more than £1,000, or if it is more than £1,000 but insignificant in relation to the amount subscribed (HMRC reads “insignificant” as trifling). Separate small receipts are added together over the period, and nothing counts as insignificant if it is received under arrangements that existed in the 12 months before the share issue.

Scenario: £50,000 EIS investment, and a £5,000 loan repaid in Year 2

Before investing, the investor lent the company £5,000. In Year 2 the company repays the loan. That is a receipt of value, and £5,000 is above the £1,000 limit.

The reduction is the smaller of 30% of the value received (£5,000 × 30% = £1,500) and the relief attributable to the shares (£15,000), so the relief is reduced by £1,500 and £13,500 is kept.

The investor must tell HMRC within 60 days of learning of the receipt. HMRC recovers the £1,500 by an assessment for the tax year in which the relief was given, not through the return for the year of the repayment.

The defensive playbook

Point 1: the termination date is a fixed line, not a sliding scaleA disposal before the termination date is treated the same whether it happens after 6 months or the day before: a gift withdraws all of the relief, and an arm’s-length sale reduces it by 30% of the proceeds. After the termination date, a sale does not affect the income tax relief, and the gain is free of Capital Gains Tax if the relief was given and not withdrawn. The date runs from the issue date on the EIS3 certificate, or from the start of trading if that is later.
Point 2: receipts of value include payments to associatesMoney or benefits the company gives the investor or an associate (a spouse, civil partner, parent, grandparent, child or grandchild, among others) from 12 months before the issue to the termination date can reduce the relief. The legislation excludes some payments, such as reasonable pay for services as a director and payments at market value for goods or services, and ignores receipts of insignificant value.
Point 3: some conditions depend on the company, not the investorThe trading, independence and other company conditions must keep being met until the termination date, and a failure withdraws the relief even though the investor did nothing. The company must tell HMRC within 60 days of an event that means a condition is no longer met. Many companies also ask HMRC for advance assurance before raising money, although that is an opinion on the plans at the time, not a guarantee.
Point 4: becoming a paid director is covered by a specific exceptionA director who receives only reasonable remuneration for services to the company can still qualify under the “business angel” rule, but only if they had never been connected with the company, or involved in its trade, before the shares were first issued to them. A director who is not paid at all, and is not otherwise connected, is not connected just by being a director.
Point 5: the certificate and the claimThe company issues a compliance certificate (form EIS3; EIS5 for an HMRC-approved fund) once it has traded for 4 months, and the relief cannot be claimed without it. The claim must be made by the fifth anniversary of the normal Self Assessment filing date for the tax year the shares were issued. The investor must tell HMRC within 60 days of coming to know of an event that withdraws or reduces relief.

What a withdrawal does and does not affect

There is no reduction for time held. The relief is not scaled down by the months left to the termination date: a disposal on the day before that date is treated in the same way as one soon after the issue. The relief is only partly kept in these cases:

Other points:

How HMRC recovers the reliefA withdrawal or reduction is made by an assessment for the tax year in which the relief was obtained, not through the return for the year of the sale or receipt. Interest runs from 31 January after that tax year, so on relief given for 2026/27 it runs from 31 January 2028, even if the assessment is raised years later. The investor must tell HMRC within 60 days of coming to know of the event.

Model EIS relief properly

The EIS/SEIS tax relief calculator handles the 30% / 50% relief, CGT deferral interaction, and shows post-tax returns under various exit scenarios.

Open the EIS/SEIS calculator →

Need an adviser? See how to find a qualified UK tax adviser.

Sources and methodology

Investor reliefs and limits from GOV.UK’s tax relief for investors using venture capital schemes; company conditions, including the gross assets limits, from GOV.UK’s EIS guidance for companies. The legislation is Part 5 of the Income Tax Act 2007: withdrawal on disposal in section 209, receipts of value in sections 213 to 216, the business angel rule for directors in section 169, the claim time limit in section 202, the assessment and interest date in sections 235 and 239, and the 60-day notices in sections 240 and 241. Detailed guidance is in the HMRC Venture Capital Schemes Manual.

UK Tax Drag is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority and does not provide regulated financial advice — see the content disclaimer for the full position. The methodology page documents how every calculator is built and reviewed.

Other tax traps deep dives

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial policy Corrections policy How we make money The Editor Methodology

UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.