For UK 2026/27: sole trader is usually best below ~£40,000 profit (simpler, similar tax, less admin). Limited company typically saves £1,500-£6,000+ per year above ~£60,000 profit, primarily through corporation tax (19%) being lower than personal tax (20%+8% NI), and tax-efficient extraction via dividends (£500 allowance at 0%, then 8.75%/33.75%/39.35%). Critical caveats: IR35 risk if your work resembles employment; extra admin cost (£500-£2,000/year accountancy); and the £60,000 profit threshold can be lower or higher depending on whether you need all the profit personally each year.
The break-even chart
Net take-home after all UK tax: sole trader vs Ltd Co (full extraction)
Net annual take-home after income tax, NI (sole trader) or corporation tax + dividend tax (Ltd Co with optimal £12,570 salary + dividends). Assumes 2026/27 rates, no Scottish bands, no employment allowance, single director, full extraction.
Sole trader - the simple option
You are the business. Profits flow directly to you and are taxed as personal income (20%/40%/45% income tax + 6%/2% Class 4 NI).
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Simple registration via SA1 | No legal separation - personal liability for debts |
| One annual tax return (until MTD ITSA) | Tax rate hits 42% at £50,270 profit |
| Free to operate (no Companies House fees) | No way to defer tax by retaining profits |
| No dividend tax to consider | Personal credit affected by business performance |
| Pension contributions get personal tax relief | Selling the business is harder |
Limited company - the structure for higher earners
The company is a separate legal entity. Profits face corporation tax first (19% small profits / up to 25% main rate). You extract via salary + dividends, with personal tax on the extracted amounts.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Lower headline tax rates above £40-50k profit | £12-£50/year Companies House filing fee + admin |
| Limited liability for shareholders | Annual accounts + corporation tax return + Self Assessment |
| Can retain profits in company at 19% CT | Accountancy typically £600-£2,500/year |
| Spousal share splitting (if genuine) | IR35 risk if work resembles employment |
| Employer pension contributions deductible | Director loans / overdrawn DLA can trigger S455 tax |
| Sale of company often more tax-efficient (BADR at 10%) | Dividend tax rates have risen sharply since 2022 |
The break-even maths - 2026/27
£50,000 profit comparison
Sole trader:
- Profit: £50,000
- Income tax: £7,486 (basic-rate on £37,700)
- Class 4 NI: £2,257 (6% on £37,700)
- Total tax: £9,743
- Net: £40,257
Limited company (£12,570 salary + £37,430 dividends):
- Profit before salary: £50,000
- Salary £12,570 (no employee NI below threshold; employer NI ~£478 if Employment Allowance not available)
- Pre-tax profit after salary: £37,430 - 478 = £36,952
- Corporation tax 19%: £7,021
- Dividend pool: £29,931
- Dividend tax: £500 at 0%, £29,431 at 8.75% = £2,575
- Total tax (CT + Div + Employer NI): £10,074
- Net: £39,926
At £50,000 profit, sole trader is roughly £330/year better. The £600+ extra accountancy cost for Ltd Co makes it materially worse. Stay sole trader.
£80,000 profit comparison
Sole trader:
- Profit: £80,000
- Income tax: £19,432
- Class 4 NI: £2,851 (6% × £37,700 + 2% × £29,730)
- Total: £22,283
- Net: £57,717
Limited company (£12,570 salary + £67,430 dividends, with pension contribution):
- Salary: £12,570; pension employer contribution: £15,000 (reduces CT)
- Pre-tax profit after salary + pension: £80,000 - 12,570 - 15,000 - 478 = £51,952
- Corporation tax: £51,952 × 26.5% marginal = £13,767
- Dividend pool: £38,185
- Dividend tax: £500 at 0%, £37,200 at 8.75%, £485 at 33.75% = £3,419
- Total tax: £17,664 + pension £15k in retirement pot
- Personal cash: £47,336 + £15k tax-deferred pension
At £80,000 profit, Ltd Co with pension extraction is roughly £4,600/year better on cash + £15,000 deferred wealth in pension. Strong case to incorporate.
When sole trader STAYS better even at higher incomes
- You need every penny of profit personally each year - no scope to retain in company
- Your spouse does not work and you cannot share dividends
- Your industry is high IR35 risk and HMRC scrutiny is intense
- You hate admin / would not properly maintain Companies House compliance
- Your business is wound down within 2-3 years - incorporation costs may not amortise
The IR35 dimension - why some contractors avoid Ltd Co entirely
The decision framework
Compare scenarios precisely
The dividend vs salary calculator models the optimal extraction at any profit level, accounting for corporation tax, dividend tax and personal allowances.
Open the dividend vs salary calculatorSources and references
Corporation tax rates from gov.uk Corporation Tax. Dividend tax rates from gov.uk tax on dividends. Class 4 NI from gov.uk Class 4 NI. IR35 rules from gov.uk IR35. Companies House fees from Companies House.
UK Tax Drag is educational and not regulated financial, tax, legal or business advice - see the disclaimer for the full position. Always verify current rates and rules at the original government sources before acting.
Other self-employed deep guides
- Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) - full UK guide
- Making Tax Digital for ITSA - 2026/27 rollout
- UK VAT schemes explained - flat rate, cash, annual
- Allowable expenses for UK self-employed
- Sole trader vs limited company - the decision
- Self-employed pension guide
- Self-employed mortgage applications
- Payments on Account explained
- Class 4 NI for the self-employed
- UK freelancer tax survival guide
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Every page is reviewed against the editorial standards, written from primary sources, sourced openly, and corrected publicly. No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.