Published fees checked on 26 September 2026: PensionBee charges one annual fee of 0.50% to 0.95% depending on the plan, halved on savings above £100,000. Penfold’s Standard plan charges 0.75% up to £100,000 and 0.4% above. Profile Pensions charges an all-inclusive 0.82% to 0.86% a year for an advised service. A DIY SIPP charges an account fee (for example Vanguard 0.15% a year, capped at £375) plus the costs of the funds chosen. UK Tax Drag does not rank or recommend providers.
The four main UK consolidation routes
| PensionBee | Penfold | Profile Pensions | DIY SIPP (examples) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yearly fee | 0.50% to 0.95% depending on the plan; half the fee on savings above £100,000 | Standard plan: 0.75% up to £100,000, 0.4% above | 0.82% to 0.86%, all-inclusive, depending on the plan chosen for you | Vanguard: £4 a month below £32,000, then 0.15% capped at £375. AJ Bell: 0.25% on funds (lower above £250,000); shares and ETFs capped at £10 a month. Interactive Investor: from £5.99 a month |
| What the fee covers | One annual fee, as described on its plans page | One annual fee covering the pension and its investments | Platform, fund and ongoing advice service | Account only; fund costs and any dealing charges are extra |
| Transfers in | Combining old pensions is free | See Penfold’s charges guide | Free for known pensions; 1% of the pension value to find lost pensions and check them | See each SIPP’s charges schedule |
| Investment choice | A range of ready-made plans | A range of ready-made plans | Plan chosen through the advice process | The investor chooses from the provider’s range |
| FSCS protection | Up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm, for eligible claims if an authorised firm fails; it does not cover falls in investment values | |||
Fees checked on 26 September 2026 on each provider’s own pages.
Yearly fees on a £150,000 pot
First-year fees on a £150,000 pot at the published rates. The specialist and advised fees are all-in as each provider describes them; the DIY SIPP figures are account charges only, with fund costs on top.
| Route | Yearly fee | What is extra |
|---|---|---|
| PensionBee (0.50% plan to 0.95% plan) | £625 to £1,187.50 | Nothing listed beyond the annual fee |
| Penfold Standard | £950 | Nothing listed beyond the annual fee |
| Profile Pensions (0.82% to 0.86%) | £1,230 to £1,290 | 1% one-off if it finds and checks lost pensions |
| Vanguard Personal Pension | £225 | Fund costs (0.06% to 0.79% on Vanguard funds) |
| AJ Bell SIPP, all in funds | £375 | Fund costs and dealing charges |
| AJ Bell SIPP, all in shares and ETFs | £120 | ETF costs and dealing charges |
| Interactive Investor Plus plan (above £100,000) | £179.88 | Fund costs and dealing charges |
PensionBee’s halving rule means the first £100,000 is charged at the plan rate and the remaining £50,000 at half of it. The SIPP comparison has the full DIY SIPP charges, including drawdown.
What each route involves
- Specialist consolidation services (PensionBee, Penfold) arrange the transfers from old providers and invest the combined pot in one of their ready-made plans for a single annual fee.
- An advised service (Profile Pensions) recommends a plan after an advice process and charges an all-inclusive yearly fee; finding lost pensions and checking them costs 1% of the pension value.
- A DIY SIPP needs the investor to request the transfers and choose the investments. The account fee is separate from the costs of the funds chosen.
Features to compare
How the fee is worked out
PensionBee and Penfold charge one percentage that falls on the part of the pot above £100,000. Profile Pensions charges an all-inclusive percentage. DIY SIPPs charge an account fee that may be capped or flat, with fund costs on top.
Who does the work
The specialist services arrange transfers for you; an advised service also recommends the investments; a DIY SIPP leaves both the transfer requests and the investment choice with the investor.
Investment choice
Specialist services offer a set of ready-made plans; a SIPP gives access to the provider’s whole range of funds, shares and ETFs.
Checks before consolidating any pension
Benefits that can be lost on a transfer
- Safeguarded benefits worth more than £30,000. Pensions with a promised level of income, such as defined benefit (final salary) pensions, count as safeguarded benefits. The law requires appropriate independent advice before transferring them if they are worth more than £30,000.
- Guaranteed annuity rates. A promised minimum rate for turning the pot into an income is also a safeguarded benefit, and a transfer gives it up.
- Protected tax-free cash above 25%. Some older pensions carry protection for a higher tax-free lump sum. HMRC’s manual explains that this protection is lost on a transfer unless it is a block transfer.
- A pension an employer is paying into now. Check with the scheme how a transfer would affect contributions still being paid in.
Check each old provider’s transfer value statement and look for any safeguarded benefits warnings or exit charges.
Plan your pension consolidation
The pension calculator projects the value of a pot at retirement using your own figures, including a yearly charge.
Open the pension calculator →How we built this comparison
Fees were checked on 26 September 2026 against each provider’s own pages: PensionBee plans, Penfold Standard plan, Profile Pensions fees, Vanguard fees, AJ Bell SIPP charges and Interactive Investor charges. The transfer checks are from GOV.UK guidance on safeguarded benefits, HMRC PTM063150 and MoneyHelper; FSCS limits from the FSCS. UK Tax Drag has no commercial relationship with any provider listed: no affiliate links, no referral codes, no sponsored content. The methodology page documents our comparison standards and the independence page our funding model.
This page is educational only and is not regulated financial advice. It compares published fees and features; it does not say whether consolidating, or which route, suits any reader. Investments can fall as well as rise.
Related
- SIPP platforms compared 2026/27: DIY SIPP charges and drawdown
- Pensions for beginners: foundation reference
- All investing content
- All calculators
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.