The short answer
Higher-rate or additional-rate taxpayer? The SIPP usually comes out ahead. Relief at 40% or 45% (up to 48% in Scotland) beats the LISA’s 25% bonus, which is worth the same as 20% relief.
Basic-rate taxpayer or non-taxpayer? The LISA usually wins, if you can open one before 40 and either want it for a first home or do not expect a high retirement income. The 25% bonus matches basic-rate relief, and withdrawals from 60 are tax-free while three-quarters of a pension withdrawal is taxed as income.
Can you use both? Yes. The LISA’s £4,000 a year limit is separate from the £60,000 pension annual allowance, so one common split is the LISA for the first £4,000 and a pension for anything above that.
The LISA is being replaced for home buying. After a consultation that ran from 22 June to 18 August 2026, Budget 2026 (28 October 2026) announced a First Time Buyer ISA that replaces the LISA for new savers from April 2029. It allows up to £4,000 a year with a 25% government bonus worked out on the balance and paid when the money is withdrawn for a first home costing up to £450,000, with the bonus capped at £20,000 and no upper age limit. Existing LISA holders can keep paying in and using their accounts under the current rules (overview of tax legislation and rates, 2.3; checked 29 October 2026). The Budget documents do not say whether new LISAs can still be opened up to the launch.
The structural comparison
| Feature | LISA | SIPP |
|---|---|---|
| Government top-up / relief | 25% bonus on contributions up to £4,000 a year (up to £1,000) | Relief at your highest Income Tax rate: 20%, 40% or 45% (up to 48% in Scotland) |
| Annual contribution limit | £4,000 a year (counts toward the £20,000 ISA allowance) | Relief on up to 100% of your UK earnings (£3,600 gross with no earnings); £60,000 annual allowance, lower if tapered or after flexible access |
| Age you can open | 18 to 39 (first payment before your 40th birthday) | Any age |
| Age you can pay in | Until your 50th birthday | Any age, but tax relief stops at 75 |
| Earliest withdrawal | 60, a first home, or terminal illness, without a charge | 55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028 |
| Tax on withdrawals | Tax-free | Usually 25% tax-free (capped at £268,275 in total), the rest taxed as income |
| Early withdrawal for any other reason | 25% withdrawal charge on the amount taken, which costs about 6.25% of your own money as well as the bonus (20% since 29 October 2026 when the money goes towards a first home above £450,000) | Not normally allowed before minimum pension age except for ill health; an unauthorised payment is taxed at up to 55% |
| Inheritance Tax | Inside your estate | Usually outside your estate for deaths before 6 April 2027; inside it for deaths from that date (Finance Act 2026) |
Worked example 1 — Basic-rate taxpayer, age 30, £4,000/year
£4,000 a year paid in at the start of each year for 30 years, 5% a year net return, no employer contribution.
- LISA route. £4,000 contribution + £1,000 government bonus = £5,000 a year invested. After 30 years at 5%: about £348,800. Withdrawn at 60, all tax-free.
- SIPP route. £4,000 contribution + £1,000 basic-rate relief added by the provider = £5,000 a year invested. The same £348,800 after 30 years. At withdrawal: 25% tax-free (£87,200) and 75% taxable as income (£261,600). If your State Pension already uses almost all of your Personal Allowance, each taxable pound is taxed at 20%: £52,300 of tax, or 15% of the whole pot, leaving about £296,500.
For a basic-rate taxpayer who stays a basic-rate taxpayer in retirement, the LISA comes out about £52,000 ahead on these assumptions, purely because its withdrawals are tax-free instead of partly taxable. An employer contribution or salary sacrifice can reverse that, because a LISA gets neither.
Worked example 2 — Higher-rate taxpayer, same £4,000/year
The same £4,000 a year out of your own pocket, but you pay 40% tax on at least £6,667 of your income. Same 5% return over 30 years.
- LISA route. Same as above: £5,000 a year invested, about £348,800 after 30 years, all tax-free at 60.
- SIPP route. A net payment of about £5,333 is grossed up to £6,667 by the provider, and you claim the extra 20% (£1,333) back through Self Assessment or your tax code, so your real cost is £4,000. £6,667 a year grows to about £465,100. After the same 15% effective tax on withdrawal, you keep about £395,300.
For the same £4,000 a year, the higher-rate taxpayer ends up about £46,500 better off in the SIPP. The gap narrows if you pay higher-rate tax in retirement too, and the higher-rate part of the relief is only given if you claim it.
The first-home use case (LISA's standout feature)
A SIPP cannot be used to buy a home before minimum pension age; the LISA can be used for a first home without the withdrawal charge. The conditions are tight but workable:
- The property costs £450,000 or less (the same cap across the UK). Since 29 October 2026, money taken out towards a first home above the cap that meets the other conditions has a 20% withdrawal charge instead of 25%, which takes back the equivalent of the bonus (Budget 2026, section 7.20).
- You have never owned a home, in the UK or anywhere else in the world.
- You buy at least 12 months after your first payment into the LISA.
- You buy with a mortgage that is not a buy-to-let mortgage and, since 6 April 2024, not from a connected person such as a relative; you will live there; and a conveyancer or solicitor receives the money and completes within 90 days (extensions are possible).
For a first-time buyer in their 20s or early 30s, the maths is clear: paying in the £4,000 limit each year adds a £1,000 government bonus each year, so £20,000 over 5 years becomes £25,000 before any growth.
The LISA calculator shows the bonus + growth path for any contribution scenario, and the first-time buyer guide covers the use of LISA as part of a deposit.
The death-benefit angle
For deaths before 6 April 2027, SIPP balances usually pass to nominated beneficiaries outside the estate for Inheritance Tax. LISA balances are inside the estate, although there is no withdrawal charge on a LISA when the holder dies. For an ordinary household the difference is often small, but for wealthier households it has been one of the main reasons to favour pensions.
For deaths on or after 6 April 2027, most unused pension funds and pension death benefits count towards the estate for Inheritance Tax. This is now law (Finance Act 2026, sections 66 to 69). The gap narrows, although a pension inherited from someone who dies at 75 or over is also taxed as the beneficiary’s income when it is drawn. The IHT guide covers the change.
Common mistakes
- Filling the LISA before taking the employer pension contribution. Under automatic enrolment an employer pays at least 3% of qualifying earnings when you pay in, and many match more. Opting out to fund a LISA gives that up, so the employer contribution is part of the comparison before choosing between a LISA and a SIPP for anything extra.
- Using the LISA for a non-qualifying withdrawal in your 30s or 40s. The 25% withdrawal charge is on the amount you take out, not on what you paid in, so you lose the bonus and a slice of your own money. A LISA is a poor fit if there is a real chance you will need the cash before 60 or a first home.
- Forgetting the age limits. You cannot pay into a LISA from your 50th birthday, or open one from your 40th. Pensions have neither limit, although tax relief stops at 75.
- Treating the LISA as a 25% return on day one. It is, but only if you keep the money in until 60 or a first home. Taking it out early for anything else turns the 25% bonus into a 6.25% loss on your own contribution, before any growth.
Sources
Every rule and figure on this page was checked against these sources on 3 October 2026. The worked examples are our own arithmetic on the stated assumptions.
- GOV.UK: Lifetime ISA: the £4,000 limit and 25% bonus, opening before 40, paying in until 50, the 25% withdrawal charge and the first-home conditions.
- Individual Savings Account Regulations 1998, Schedule, paragraph 6: a first-time buyer has never owned a home in the UK or elsewhere.
- HMRC: Lifetime ISA withdrawals for a first time residential purchase (updated 10 April 2024): the buy-to-let mortgage exclusion, the rule from 6 April 2024 that the mortgage cannot come from a connected person, and the 90-day completion rule and its extensions.
- HM Treasury: First Time Buyer ISA consultation (ran from 22 June 2026 to 18 August 2026): the replacement for the LISA.
- HM Treasury, Budget 2026 (28 October 2026), sections 6.1 and 7.20, and the overview of tax legislation and rates, 2.3 and 2.4: the First Time Buyer ISA from April 2029 and the 20% LISA charge for first homes above £450,000 from 29 October 2026 (checked 29 October 2026).
- GOV.UK: pension tax relief and annual allowance: relief at your highest rate on up to 100% of earnings, £3,600 with no earnings, and the £60,000 allowance.
- GOV.UK: tax when you get a pension: 25% tax-free up to £268,275.
- GOV.UK: early retirement and your pension: access usually from 55, and up to 55% tax on unauthorised payments.
- Finance Act 2022, section 10: minimum pension age rising to 57 on 6 April 2028; Finance Act 2004, section 188(3): no relief on contributions paid from age 75.
- Finance Act 2026 (Royal Assent 18 March 2026), sections 66 to 69: pensions in the estate for deaths on or after 6 April 2027.
- GOV.UK: workplace pensions, what you and your employer pay: the 3% employer minimum.
How UK Tax Drag holds itself to account
Pages are checked against the primary sources listed on each page and reviewed by the Editor; corrections are logged in the changelog. Pages are drafted with the help of AI tools (how AI is used). No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.
UK Tax Drag is an independent publication by Finsolve Consulting Limited, not affiliated with or endorsed by HMRC, GOV.UK or any government body.