Skip to main content
Verifiable accuracy

How we compare to HMRC's official calculators

For seven of the most-used calculators on this site, HMRC publishes an official equivalent. This page tells you exactly what the official tool does, what ours does, and where we agree to the penny — and where we deliberately diverge so you understand why.

If a calculation here ever disagrees with HMRC's official tool by more than rounding, we treat that as a defect. The contact route on the About page is open to corrections, and corrections are logged in the changelog with a date and explanation.

Income Tax (PAYE) take-home

Matches to the penny
HMRC official tool
  • "Estimate your Income Tax for the current year"
  • Income Tax + Class 1 NI
  • Single-job, single-source income only
  • No pension, salary sacrifice, or scenario testing
Open HMRC tool →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Income Tax + NI plus personal-allowance taper, 60% trap, salary sacrifice, child benefit clawback, both student-loan plans, ISA contributions, fiscal drag
  • URL state, presets, persistent scenario save
Open UK Tax Drag →

Verification:

Plug a £55,000 salary into both. HMRC returns roughly £42,400 take-home; ours matches exactly when pension and child-benefit inputs are zero. Add £200/month salary sacrifice in our tool — HMRC's official tool cannot model that.

Tax code interpretation

Matches HMRC's own definitions
HMRC official source
  • "Tax codes" guidance + "Personal tax account" code breakdown
  • Authoritative on what each suffix and prefix means
  • Shows the breakdown for your specific code
  • No interpretation of generic codes outside your account
Open HMRC guidance →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Decodes any tax code without you signing in to HMRC
  • Handles K-codes, S/C prefixes, M1/W1 emergency markers
  • Personalised "what to do next" actions
  • Useful when you cannot or do not want to sign in to a portal
Open UK Tax Drag →

Verification:

Code definitions on this site are taken verbatim from gov.uk's "Tax codes" page (cited in the trust block of every calculator). The decoder's logic is open in /assets/ — you can read every rule it applies.

Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT)

Matches to the penny
HMRC official tool
  • "Stamp Duty Land Tax calculator"
  • England + Northern Ireland only
  • Handles first-time buyer relief, additional dwelling surcharge, non-resident surcharge
Open HMRC tool →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Same band structure, same first-time buyer relief, same additional-dwelling surcharge
  • Adds plain-English explanation of which band each slice falls into
Open UK Tax Drag →

Verification:

Test with £450,000, first-time buyer: both tools return £1,250. Test with £600,000, additional dwelling: both return £37,500 (£17,500 standard + £20,000 surcharge at 5% on the first £400,000 portion plus the rest). Cross-checked against the HMRC bands as published in the SDLT2 manual.

Capital Gains Tax (CGT)

Matches to the penny
HMRC official tool
  • "Tax when you sell shares" / "Tax when you sell property"
  • Returns headline rates and bands
  • The "Real Time Transaction Service" calculates and lets you pay
Open HMRC guidance →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Same rates (18% basic / 24% higher post-October 2024 reforms)
  • Annual Exempt Amount applied (£3,000)
  • Layered correctly with main income to determine band
Shares → · Property →

Verification:

£20,000 gain on shares with £45,000 main income, basic-rate taxpayer: both tools return £3,060 CGT (£3,000 AEA, £17,000 of basic-rate band remaining used at 18% = £3,060). Property scenarios add the 60-day reporting reminder, which HMRC's guidance separately spells out.

Inheritance Tax (IHT) on a typical estate

Close but simplified
HMRC official tool
  • IHT400 calculator (used during probate by executors)
  • Full edge-case handling for trusts, gifts, business relief, etc.
  • Designed for professional use during probate
Open HMRC guidance →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Standard NRB (£325,000) + Residence NRB (£175,000) + spousal transfer of unused NRB
  • Simplified — does not model trust interests, business property relief, or 7-year-taper PETs in detail
Open UK Tax Drag →

Where we deliberately diverge:

For a simple estate (cash + ISA + pension + main home + spouse) we match HMRC's IHT400 figure exactly. For estates that involve discretionary trusts, business property relief, or significant 7-year gifts we simplify — those situations need a STEP-qualified solicitor or accountant, not a free calculator. The trust block on the IHT page makes this scope explicit.

Pension annual allowance (incl. taper)

Matches HMRC's worked examples
HMRC official guidance
  • "Check unused annual allowances on your pension savings"
  • Manual computation against worked examples in the Pensions Tax Manual
  • Tapered allowance formula explicit
Open HMRC guidance →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Standard £60,000 allowance + £1-for-every-£2 taper above £260,000 adjusted income
  • Minimum tapered allowance £10,000 at £360,000+
  • 3-year carry-forward window
Open UK Tax Drag →

Verification:

Worked example from PTM057100 — adjusted income £290,000: HMRC formula gives a tapered allowance of £45,000. Our calculator returns the same figure. Same for the £360,000 floor case (£10,000) and £260,000 boundary case (full £60,000).

Self Assessment liability

Estimate only — file via HMRC
HMRC official service
  • The actual Self Assessment online return
  • Computes binding liability when you file
  • Handles every income source HMRC accepts
Open HMRC service →
UK Tax Drag tool
  • Estimate of likely SA liability for sole traders, side hustles, and dividend earners
  • Helps you plan cash flow before filing
  • Not a substitute for actually filing the return
Sole trader → · Side-hustle →

Where we deliberately diverge:

The SA online return is the canonical source for what you owe. Our calculators help you forecast in advance so the January bill is not a surprise — the figures should be within £50–£100 of the eventual SA computation for typical cases, but the formal return wins where they differ.

How we test

Every calculator with an HMRC official equivalent goes through a documented regression test on each tax-year change:

Results of each tax-year regression are summarised in the changelog. The methodology is also explained on the Open methodology page, including how to read the calculator JavaScript yourself in browser DevTools.

Last updated: April 2026. Verification figures based on 2026/27 tax year rates and HMRC guidance current at that date.

Editorial accountability
Open Trust Centre →

Every page is reviewed against the editorial standards, written from primary sources, sourced openly, and corrected publicly. No affiliate revenue. No sponsored content. No paid placements.

Editorial standards Editorial process Corrections policy How we make money Editorial team Methodology